I think this is taking longer than it should imo. I thought they'd have it by at least late Dec./late Jan. Although to be fair, it looked like they were still hiring people for the 2nd team recently (perhaps even now) so maybe they couldn't REALLY get things going until a few months ago.
The bitch of it is they are barely giving us any sort of news or ANYTHING to build up hype. All we've seen was a few images of in game action which of course looks exactly like q3 but with a new skin.
id software are like Blizzard, they delay the game for an insane amount of time to improve the game quality. Except, id software games are still shit upon release, Its a lose lose situation for everyone.
It's good to see idsoftware has continued to firmly take a stance to not give us any updates, comments or try to build up any sort of hype surrounding this project. That is a sure fire way to achieve success right there.
It's not bad, but it's faaaaaar from finished. The balance is terrible, the feat trees are terrible, lack of level content, bugs (major ones, not just tiny little ones), game perfomance etc.
If they really work hard on the game it could be very good yes. But defo not a WoW killer.