Used a CRT myself for a long time. Eventually got an Asus VG248QE and have been using that for about two years. Very happy with it. There's a lot less eye strain from using LCDs, I think. Feels better to play on.
Pretty much any 120hz+ Asus, Benq or Eizo is okay - not quite CRT but close enough that you should be satisfied. Biggest problem is poor color accuracy. 120hz+ IPS exist for better colors but they suffer from slower pixel response.