Quake2 is the king, babe...
I wish now after playing so much q3 and ql that I would been playing Quake2 instead.
What comes in second is Quake1 and Doom3 I see them at same level of good.
Quake3 is better than Quakelive because a bit more raw settings -random spawn, increased rail, damage through floor, and so on (I am talking about the raw Quake3 here, all patched and refined versions and mods are sh1t). And Quakelive is better than Quake champions because they f-ed quake in champions with fast champions (decreased hitbox = aim is even more important) and the addition of superpower powerups that you pick, which were bad conceived and all), on the bright side QC have that superior level of customization skins and all.
C A R M A C K
A
R
M
A
C
K