ESR - Quake Co-Creator John Carmack Leaves id

<< Comment #1 @ 15:20 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

h8m3

:(

12%

<< Comment #118 @ 02:20 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

PopeJo - Reply to #1

:((

<< Comment #136 @ 05:14 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

h8m3 - Reply to #118

:(((

<< Comment #183 @ 11:02 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Fr0zzen - Reply to #136

:((((

<< Comment #198 @ 14:55 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

eburbeck - Reply to #183

turn that frown upside down

)))):

<< Comment #220 @ 08:22 CST, 24 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

losty - Reply to #198

))):

<< Comment #223 @ 10:50 CST, 24 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

p4r4 - Reply to #220

:((( ))):

<< Comment #2 @ 15:24 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

sleepii

probably saw doom 4, realized it sucked mushroom tip, and left

noggnore

<< Comment #3 @ 15:27 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

hitsu

well, maybe now id will make good games

11%

<< Comment #5 @ 15:32 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

goodbye_world - Reply to #3

Carmack was all the company had going for it. Disband, id Software. It's time.

9%

<< Comment #14 @ 15:46 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Curious - Reply to #5

Was Carmack involved with RAGE?

<< Comment #18 @ 15:52 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

goodbye_world - Reply to #14

Let me put it this way. Carmack is a majestic eagle forced to soar the winds adorned in a crown of albatrosses. No longer. Understand?

23%

<< Comment #91 @ 19:04 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

jamalz - Reply to #18

nigga is dat klingon?

37%

<< Comment #206 @ 16:43 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

[mash] - Reply to #91

oh my god. that made my day.

<< Comment #113 @ 02:05 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

FlashSoul - Reply to #14

Yes. He made the engine.

<< Comment #174 @ 09:17 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

p0rt - Reply to #113

did the renderer and nothing much else, and spent most of his time making his spaceships

<< Comment #126 @ 04:05 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

MajkiFajki - Reply to #3

Last really good and visionary game by ID was when "first" ID was almost done - it was Quake3 Arena. After that it was only "game manufacturing", not visionary gamedev like in the past.

And real losses for ID were ppl Like Romero or McGee, not Carmack.

10%

<< Comment #4 @ 15:31 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

sTPHN

First Strenx, now John. What's next?

<< Comment #9 @ 15:38 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

SIHdW3W - Reply to #4

you forget about blaze : (

2%

<< Comment #6 @ 15:34 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Phyrigian

john to start a new company pls i want good games again.

9%

<< Comment #148 @ 05:51 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Rothaarig3 - Reply to #6

pls NO consoleshit !

consoles are quite not good enough for occulus rift, too much latency

Xbox One, PS4 "too limited" for Oculus Rift, says creator

who cares, he started this console shit and working on games for handhelds like mac shit

7%

<< Comment #19 @ 15:53 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

p0rt

hes brought nullsoft for shoutcast and oculus rift streaming service

<< Comment #7 @ 15:37 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Shardik

Oh nooo ! No more key notes !!??

<< Comment #11 @ 15:40 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Venser - Reply to #7

"If they don't want me to talk on stage at Quakecon next year, we'll just have to fill up the lobby like the old days. :-)"

https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/403986360731594752

16%

<< Comment #17 @ 15:50 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Demiurge ' - Reply to #11

Haha, what an awesome guy :)

3%

<< Comment #141 @ 05:30 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

sirax - Reply to #11

Maybe they will stream the games properly rather than 6hr yawn fest :X

13%

<< Comment #123 @ 03:53 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Xsi - Reply to #7

Yeah, more proposals!

<< Comment #8 @ 15:37 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Venser

Fuck :(

<< Comment #10 @ 15:38 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

MaGGoTkil

not cool

7%

<< Comment #12 @ 15:41 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

u3a6

Who will make game engines with that lag less feel :|

<< Comment #15 @ 15:47 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

yu_raider - Reply to #12

Are you kidding me? Hitboxes (hitcylinders or whatever) still lag behind the model... and it's 2013!

10%

<< Comment #21 @ 15:56 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

sTPHN - Reply to #15

You can't aim then :(

10%

<< Comment #26 @ 16:02 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

yu_raider - Reply to #21

You trolling or you seriously never noticed this?

<< Comment #41 @ 16:33 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Lam ' - Reply to #26

For us, people who don't spend 3/4 of our lives spectating others (lolca), there's no problem ;)

(Hint: spectating and watching demos is not client view. It's server view before unlagging.)

<< Comment #47 @ 16:37 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

yu_raider - Reply to #41

It happens for rails in the game as well when not speccing. Either that or the hitbox is a lot larger than keel :P

Edited by yu_raider at 16:38 CST, 22 November 2013

<< Comment #49 @ 16:47 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Laim - Reply to #47

If i remember correctly the hitbox is larger then keel. Actually the area behind him is where it is larger, or if that was on some other model.

<< Comment #50 @ 16:50 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

yu_raider - Reply to #49

If that's the case, id should totally put a jetpack on keel's back \m/_

<< Comment #53 @ 16:56 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Laim - Reply to #50

http://img651.imageshack.us/img651/4573/4keellateral.jpg

Here you go.

EDIT: added front view: http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/827/1keelfrontal.jpg/

EDIT OF EDIT: Fuck it have all angles

Tankjr: http://img862.imageshack.us/img862/2039/tankjrall.jpg

Keel: http://img716.imageshack.us/img716/1781/keelall.jpg

Grunt: http://img852.imageshack.us/img852/1261/gruntall.jpg

Doom: http://img823.imageshack.us/img823/9189/doomall.jpg

Edited by Laim at 17:07 CST, 22 November 2013

27%

<< Comment #62 @ 17:26 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Terbo - Reply to #53

At this point we've all been playing long enough you should just sense where the hit box is. Use the Quake force!

9%

<< Comment #76 @ 18:19 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Laim - Reply to #62

Pretty much. If i miss my shots it isn't because of the hitbox is a few inches wrong.

<< Comment #81 @ 18:29 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

jigglywiggly - Reply to #76

no
the hitboxes are different for different people because the netcode is so bad(depending on their netgraph and rate, etc)

client side hit detection pls quake live 2.0

Edited by jigglywiggly at 18:30 CST, 22 November 2013

5%

<< Comment #84 @ 18:38 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Laim - Reply to #81

[-]

<< Comment #170 @ 08:41 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Smofo - Reply to #84

The hitboxes differ from person to person for me too, I don't know why you're disagreeing with him ?

<< Comment #202 @ 16:07 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Laim - Reply to #170

Because of "client side hit detection". Client side hit detection have always been shit.

<< Comment #96 @ 20:18 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

naper - Reply to #81

"client side hit detection"
That will never be abused....

25%

<< Comment #95 @ 19:54 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

adrenal1ne - Reply to #62

just play q2

2%

<< Comment #121 @ 03:14 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

PerpetualWar - Reply to #49

Hm, so what's the best way to set lean on ? I mean lean 1 is surely not representing hitbox correctly, right ?

<< Comment #79 @ 18:25 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

jigglywiggly - Reply to #21

dis is sign of total screb

the hitboxes for quake are bad

and needs to be client side with interpolation for warpers

that and or client side

Edited by jigglywiggly at 18:30 CST, 22 November 2013

<< Comment #169 @ 08:22 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

yu_raider - Reply to #79

no

9%

<< Comment #133 @ 04:39 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

u3a6 - Reply to #15

I wasn't talking about netcode. I was talking about the overall responsiveness of the game (mouse input etc).

<< Comment #23 @ 16:00 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

hitsu - Reply to #12

he was responsible only for gfx anyway

<< Comment #24 @ 16:02 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Demiurge ' - Reply to #23

Not really, he was responsible for the entire engine architecture down to small details, like physics and networking. I think, if I remember the .plan updates correctly, he was also very involved in weapon balance design, although he had some whacky ideas.

Edited by Demiurge at 16:04 CST, 22 November 2013

5%

<< Comment #75 @ 18:19 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Kristus - Reply to #23

He was the reson id made Quake 3.

<< Comment #98 @ 21:10 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Anonymous (24.141.206.107) - Reply to #75

that-was-a-long-time-ago-homie-things-change-he-hasn't-cared-about-us-for-a-piece

<< Comment #103 @ 22:18 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

zb0t - Reply to #98

Is this what you did with your keyboard?

10%

<< Comment #13 @ 15:41 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

lama3oid

sad day...

10%

<< Comment #16 @ 15:49 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

yu_raider

I kinda feel very negative about this... Not so much because John left iD, but because he left to develop Oculus Rift; and seeing even Carmack going the path of "immersion" over gameplay means we're probably in for at least another very very sad decade for gaming.

<< Comment #32 @ 16:17 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Pushpabon - Reply to #16

Oculus and VR will be the best thing gaming has ever seen IF they can fix 3 things:

High enough resolution.
High enough FOV.
Low enough latency with 100+ Hz.

<< Comment #150 @ 05:52 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Rothaarig3 - Reply to #32

http://www.gamespot.com/articles/xbox-one-ps4...0-6416153/

<< Comment #155 @ 06:07 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Pushpabon - Reply to #150

I ignore console garbage. PC master race represent. Watch 10 seconds of any high level quake player and any gamepad console noob will notice why. Not saying you are one, just generally.

Edited by Pushpabon at 06:09 CST, 23 November 2013

<< Comment #232 @ 04:20 CST, 25 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Rothaarig3 - Reply to #155

i played from 1999 to 2002/3 Quake3Arena & UT on the Dreamcast console with Keyboard & Mouse & MadCatz Gamepad for strafing !

and YES you can ignore it, i do it too, occulus prior is the console, now it would not run properly on them but they all are seeing the BIG $ sign

Edited by Rothaarig3 at 04:23 CST, 25 November 2013

<< Comment #38 @ 16:27 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

megaman3 - Reply to #16

VR will never be an influence, unless prices drop substantially.

The cool and trendy games are released for the cool and trendy hardware, having in mind their most used controllers and playing conditions. A $300 accessory will not be, becoming a niche (just like QL is) and not the route to be followed by mainstream media.

Still it's going to be awesome.

<< Comment #157 @ 06:17 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

tbone - Reply to #38

It's $300 and it just came out, that is pretty impressive, which means in 2 years it might be less than half that price.

The problems mentioned above are exactly what JC is working on at the moment.

The target market will definitely be the hardcore gamers, but I could definitely see myself playing immersive single player games with it.

<< Comment #20 @ 15:55 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

cumrag

i like how he types Id instead of id

<< Comment #77 @ 18:21 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Kristus - Reply to #20

That's because it's a name of a company. Names are spelled with a capital letter at the beginning.

<< Comment #85 @ 18:39 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Laim - Reply to #77

iCE cLIMBERS?

3%

<< Comment #236 @ 21:12 CST, 25 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

rep - Reply to #85

Bunch of noobs.

25%

<< Comment #120 @ 02:21 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

xou - Reply to #20

That makes me SO nervous.

<< Comment #176 @ 09:37 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

viaIImaximus - Reply to #120

now now.. we don't want you to start spreadin' rabies.

Edited by viaIImaximus at 09:37 CST, 23 November 2013

<< Comment #34 @ 16:18 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Anonymous (80.187.109.14)

truth is he had to leave to officialy hook up with 2gd for reborn

7%

<< Comment #229 @ 01:24 CST, 25 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

filo - Reply to #34

... that would be, like ... the ultimate xmas present for the fps gaming.

<< Comment #22 @ 15:57 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Ur1ch

There's some trend, I hope It's not bad

<< Comment #25 @ 16:02 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

mouse*

What did Sothis do now? I said it right from the beginning this boy is up to no good.

55%

<< Comment #27 @ 16:02 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

wrong person

good night, sweet prince :<

<< Comment #28 @ 16:07 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

megaman3

Further info about the state of the company in 2013:
http://www.esreality.com/post/2440748/todd-hollenshead-leaves-id/
http://kotaku.com/five-years-and-nothing-to-s...-468097062

<< Comment #42 @ 16:34 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Anonymous (79.168.62.163) - Reply to #28

you forgot ttimo
http://www.bluesnews.com/s/138782/ttimo-id-lo...rds-the-pc

5%

<< Comment #180 @ 09:43 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

AnthonyJ - Reply to #42

Matt hooper. - http://www.polygon.com/2013/8/8/4603846/ex-id...-oculus-vr
Brian Harris - http://www.linkedin.com/in/brianisawesome

But people joining too:
http://www.polygon.com/2013/8/5/4584682/why-t...d-software

Edited by AnthonyJ at 09:44 CST, 23 November 2013

<< Comment #184 @ 11:26 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

hemostick - Reply to #180

Kevin Cloud is still there... but has not been the art lead anymore for a while it would seem :/

<< Comment #185 @ 11:59 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

AnthonyJ - Reply to #184

Ah, but listed on LinkedIn as executive producer, so promoted I guess.

Looks like Robert and pat Duffy are still there too, also names dating back to q3 era and before.

<< Comment #29 @ 16:07 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

A1RMAN

Damn. The next news could be "id leaves game development business".

<< Comment #253 @ 02:36 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Badb0y - Reply to #29

lol, so what they gonna do instead?

<< Comment #259 @ 09:11 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

A1RMAN - Reply to #253

Engines. Technical support for Bethesda. etc

<< Comment #30 @ 16:08 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Ffleri

id does not exist without Carmack
all hail the king of gaming

thank you for Quake

Edited by Ffleri at 16:08 CST, 22 November 2013

3%

<< Comment #31 @ 16:12 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Nalipotanka

I seriously doubt we'll see proper id tech 6 any time soon. Even if we do, it will be not be on the same level as would Carmack do it, so...

And as someone mentioned, he probably saw what team did with Doom 4 and his engine and he didn't want to be involved with that. :)

But the real truth I think it happened is that Zenimax and Bethesda always have the final word with everything concerning id and he doesn't agree with that...so, it's better to leave and do something what you want than something what other people say to you.

EDIT:

Future of Quake is at stake here... :(

Edited by Nalipotanka at 16:54 CST, 22 November 2013

<< Comment #117 @ 02:17 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

FlashSoul - Reply to #31

I seriously doubt we'll see proper id tech 6 any time soon.

I don't think it's needed. id tech 5 should be well enough for the new consoles. We're gonna have to wait a long time before the next generation. PC? There's no market for that, so forget it.

<< Comment #177 @ 09:37 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

viaIImaximus - Reply to #31

mmm... napolitanka..

<< Comment #33 @ 16:17 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Joker_

Goodbye quake, I will miss you :(

The best game series ever won't be the same again

5%

<< Comment #35 @ 16:21 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

kevz

rip id...

but theres an upside, carmack is awesomesauce and i hope the oculus rift will be awesome too :>

2%

<< Comment #36 @ 16:22 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

skulp

it's over guys. :(

5%

<< Comment #178 @ 09:38 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

viaIImaximus - Reply to #36

no it's not! it's just startin'! WC 2014 here we come!

<< Comment #37 @ 16:24 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Weird

The one spark of hope inside ID has left :(

<< Comment #44 @ 16:34 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Anonymous (79.168.62.163)

2009 - quake will never die
2010 - quake rules
2011 - quake is still popular
2012 - quake is surviving
2013 - quake is still alive
2014 - gg

6%

<< Comment #46 @ 16:37 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

skulp - Reply to #44

ouch gg

<< Comment #54 @ 16:58 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

goodbye_world - Reply to #44

2008 - Vast amount of potential for Quake Live.
2009 - Listen to your community.
2010 - Why aren't you listening?
2011 - Gettin` real tired of your shit.
2012 - Dead
2013 - Dead
2014 - QL 2.0!!!!! STANDFOREVERALONEDOA EDITION!!!

26%

<< Comment #122 @ 03:31 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

NastyTime - Reply to #44

I hope you are wrong.

<< Comment #43 @ 16:34 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

innox

Annnnnd that's a wrap folks. Reborn anyone?

<< Comment #39 @ 16:29 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

fuzz

Bail from already sunk ship.

<< Comment #40 @ 16:30 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

pacmanpl

Syncerror will be next...
For those about to Quake, we salute you

3%

<< Comment #45 @ 16:34 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

!nFerNo

Good things can't last forever...

<< Comment #48 @ 16:47 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

z4t01

the day that quake really died

we have the money....now we must try to rebuild it.

better.
faster.
stronger.
less idiots.

<< Comment #52 @ 16:52 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Nalipotanka - Reply to #48

Who is we? Who has the money to make a game?

<< Comment #56 @ 17:02 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Laim - Reply to #52

Jamerio!

7%

<< Comment #57 @ 17:03 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

newborn - Reply to #48

Working on it!

27%

<< Comment #108 @ 23:46 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

23 - Reply to #57

Warsow with better character designs?

<< Comment #116 @ 02:17 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

H1ghlander - Reply to #108

new engine

<< Comment #127 @ 04:24 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

pacmanpl - Reply to #116

#1 on list of things that will not happen o/

<< Comment #143 @ 05:31 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

newborn - Reply to #127

A new engine is already happening. I just used it to test the new input code, in a map, on a server.

6%

<< Comment #51 @ 16:52 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

H1ghlander

quit -> make another company -> ??? -> kickstarter -> profit

???

18%

<< Comment #55 @ 16:58 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Raist - Reply to #51

this.

just imagine a kickstarter with carmack talking for 5-10 mins and some concept art thrown in about a fps he will make. ppl will throw Money on the screen just for that.

7%

<< Comment #60 @ 17:18 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Venser - Reply to #55

I don't think he wants that tho. He seems to be really enjoying working on Oculus.

<< Comment #71 @ 18:09 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Raist - Reply to #60

oh i doubt he would do it, but he would succeed in getting funds easily if he did

<< Comment #104 @ 22:33 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

danstar - Reply to #71

you actually think he has a need to.

<< Comment #145 @ 05:42 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Raist - Reply to #104

nope, just imagining the what-if

<< Comment #160 @ 07:16 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Bob - Reply to #60

.

Edited by Bob at 21:43 CDT, 26 June 2024

<< Comment #112 @ 02:01 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

marle - Reply to #55

5-10 mins
sure ;')

11%

<< Comment #146 @ 05:42 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Raist - Reply to #112

hehe yeah more like 5 hours true

<< Comment #58 @ 17:03 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

megaman3 - Reply to #51

Or work in 2GD's Reborn.

<< Comment #59 @ 17:04 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

newborn

I think Sync is the only id software employee I can name now.

<< Comment #68 @ 17:45 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Anonymous (79.168.62.163) - Reply to #59

and the least important unless map maker ranks above programmer

<< Comment #82 @ 18:32 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

jigglywiggly - Reply to #68

2bad all the maps are awful

they need to be wide and open, not turbobad maps like rats of steel where it's a cluster of grenade spam

the two good maps eyetoeye and thunderstruck aren't even from ID

Edited by jigglywiggly at 09:28 CST, 23 November 2013

<< Comment #119 @ 02:21 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

FlashSoul - Reply to #82

Please tell me this is some weird form of sarcasm.

9%

<< Comment #129 @ 04:25 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

pacmanpl - Reply to #82

go play UT

<< Comment #138 @ 05:25 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

zealot - Reply to #82

:DDDDDDDDDDDD

ever played tdm?

<< Comment #65 @ 17:42 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

!nFerNo - Reply to #59

and sponge?

<< Comment #175 @ 09:34 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

AnthonyJ - Reply to #59

I guess you know Tim Willits, and Jan Paul van Waveren (aka mrElusive, the q3 bots guy, but if you read any of his very interesting papers now does many core things).

And you may have come across Marty Stratton a few times in interviews etc.

Edited by AnthonyJ at 09:37 CST, 23 November 2013

<< Comment #188 @ 12:54 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

newborn - Reply to #175

Ah yeah, Willits and mrElusive. For some reason I thought Marty had left too but a quick google proves me wrong.

<< Comment #218 @ 05:04 CST, 24 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Anonymous (81.193.180.229) - Reply to #188

soon

<< Comment #252 @ 02:33 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Badb0y - Reply to #175

Tim Willits and Kevin Cloud do mangement now, left the creative positions.

Todd Hollenshead, Matt Hooper, Brian Harris left.

<< Comment #251 @ 02:30 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Badb0y - Reply to #59

i can name more. but you got a point. whats missing is some sort of coverage. but the rule seems to be, you only going to the press if you have a product where you talk about. in the rage period bethesda did 5 interviews with unknown worker.

http://www.bethblog.com/index.php/2011/10/05/...awn-casey/
http://www.bethblog.com/index.php/2011/09/28/...t-memmott/
http://www.bethblog.com/index.php/2011/09/22/...-mitchell/
http://www.bethblog.com/index.php/2011/09/14/...ica-stead/
http://www.bethblog.com/index.php/2011/09/07/...w-michler/

today we dont even know whos creative and art chief on doom4.

<< Comment #61 @ 17:19 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

MarzenGold

Good for him, he has done amazing things for id. But with modern engines like UE with probably 100 people working on it it is hard to still compete. And he loves the hardware side of things he is now doing for Occulus. And I hopes he manages to create an awesome product for Star Citizen and the like :)

I think he will return one day and probably develop one more game before calling it quits.

<< Comment #63 @ 17:27 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

MarzenGold - Reply to #61

And also he has spawned a child that is programming. :) So don't fret maybe little Carmack will be making amazing new Quake in 12 years time,

<< Comment #67 @ 17:45 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Anonymous (94.225.162.229)

Games have become too big for one person to controll everything. Even if he had stayed, what were you guys expecting anyway?

<< Comment #64 @ 17:32 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Venim

Well all good things come to an end...

Yes this is really the end of id.

<< Comment #66 @ 17:43 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Le0

Well, finally.

<< Comment #69 @ 17:58 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

gSTRUCTOR '

Why this has to happen 1 week before the best quake tournament ever? :/

Life wont be the same anymore, i has sad.

C A R M A C K
A
R
M
A
C
K

2%

<< Comment #257 @ 06:11 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Rothaarig3 - Reply to #69

22. Nov 2013 is also the 50th annyversary of the John F. Kennedy Assassination, what an incident ...

<< Comment #70 @ 18:03 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Torzelan

On one hand it feels like a big deal 'cause, you know. Damn.
On the other... Not really cared for anything "new" he/they did since at least Quake 4 (which also wasn't as good as Q3 but fun enough while it lasted) so... Shrug, guess QL is more or less unaffected and hopefully Carmack helps Oculus be the best they can be? Sounds good to me.

<< Comment #74 @ 18:16 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

gSTRUCTOR ' - Reply to #70

Q4 was done by Raven, not id.

<< Comment #80 @ 18:26 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Torzelan - Reply to #74

Well sure, but at least id collaborated/supervised and provided id Tech 4. If that doesn't count then yeah it was even longer ago.

<< Comment #167 @ 07:58 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

qahdrk - Reply to #74

id was responsible for the patches cuz q4 came pretty shitty, they made 1.3 and 1.42 for the better

<< Comment #72 @ 18:09 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

amalik

,

Edited by amalik at 18:10 CST, 22 November 2013

94%

<< Comment #78 @ 18:25 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Anonymous (2.93.129.22) - Reply to #72

xactly)))

<< Comment #73 @ 18:15 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

gSTRUCTOR ' - Reply to #72

LOLOLOL

<< Comment #101 @ 21:15 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Mariano - Reply to #72

Full HD CRT <3 :D

27%

<< Comment #189 @ 13:02 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

syncore - Reply to #72

comment of the year, imo

<< Comment #83 @ 18:37 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

FFT

Well as far I am concerned he already left months ago when he joined up with oculus rift. It was clear he was not interested in working for id anymore and just prepared a transition period for his final leave.

6%

<< Comment #250 @ 02:22 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Badb0y - Reply to #83

i wasnt sure that it happened

<< Comment #86 @ 18:40 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

gisele

CU @ Qcon, Mr. Carmack :D

<< Comment #87 @ 18:42 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

kluczmen

we all know that id software were good ad making games when you could see all the credits on one page without scrolling, don't know if there's a single relevant person from q3/rtcw days that works there right now, and we all know that these gameplay/artstyle designers were making the difference why their games had their distinct vibe, now it's officially over,

propably doom4 is going to be a mixture of copy pasting gameplay elements from their old games and complete horseshit, just like rage was, that's it

3%

<< Comment #89 @ 18:57 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

gSTRUCTOR ' - Reply to #87

> we all know that id software were good ad making games when you could see all the credits on one page without scrolling

Best description ever :D

<< Comment #154 @ 06:06 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Pirx - Reply to #89

that's the problem with games today, they're too complex to be made by a few people, like when they made doom and quake.

<< Comment #158 @ 06:36 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

gSTRUCTOR ' - Reply to #154

agree

<< Comment #88 @ 18:53 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

c3rb

Oh God, now that's truely the end of an era. I'm not even sure if id has a point to keep on existing without him on board.

Move along folks, there's nothing left to see :(

<< Comment #249 @ 02:22 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Badb0y - Reply to #88

let them prove your wrong.

<< Comment #276 @ 06:08 CST, 1 December 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

c3rb - Reply to #249

That's what we are all asking for, I guess.

<< Comment #90 @ 19:00 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

gSTRUCTOR '

Edited by gSTRUCTOR at 19:01 CST, 22 November 2013

29%

<< Comment #115 @ 02:15 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Whipas - Reply to #90

ye. i have tu + u there

<< Comment #179 @ 09:39 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

viaIImaximus - Reply to #90

haha awesome movie xD

<< Comment #212 @ 19:23 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

jamalz - Reply to #179

what movie?

also looky what I found when looking for that gif

http://gifrific.com/reaction-gifs/#

<< Comment #219 @ 06:40 CST, 24 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

viaIImaximus - Reply to #212

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0286106/

<< Comment #92 @ 19:09 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

m8

lol, chill y'all, it was all over before Q4 release, or maybe even right after Q3 release, 14 years ago.

I'm glad he will not have anything in common with that PHP embarrassment anymore.

<< Comment #97 @ 20:31 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

jigglywiggly - Reply to #92

so brave

3%

<< Comment #93 @ 19:22 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

holy_b33r

oh shit

<< Comment #94 @ 19:35 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

gSTRUCTOR ' - Reply to #93

shit just got real

<< Comment #99 @ 21:10 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Anonymous (95.154.230.253)

Carmack is inherently evil because he is a ginger.

<< Comment #100 @ 21:14 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

weltschmerz

Well, they sold out their company while they still could get a good price for their shares, didn't they. I can hardly consider this a surprise

<< Comment #102 @ 22:15 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Nuked User

* N U K E D *

<< Comment #165 @ 07:40 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Demiurge ' - Reply to #102

yes, looking at the comments, not a single

<< Comment #193 @ 13:39 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Nuked User - Reply to #165

* N U K E D *

<< Comment #197 @ 14:42 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Demiurge ' - Reply to #193

wow, you seem to really give a fuck

<< Comment #200 @ 15:21 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Nuked User - Reply to #197

* N U K E D *

<< Comment #248 @ 02:21 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Badb0y - Reply to #200

>id software hasn't been relevant for a while.

relevant is a big word, like someone did a revolutionary thing or set a trend. in this case your maybe right. but if you give me doom3/rage or battlefield/cod i take the first one.

after rage i saw the enemytype, mutant behaviour running on walls and ceiling, in two new FPS games. they still get citated in games.

personally i dont like the vibe here, its like there is quake on a podest and all dancing around it and in a dark corner is id. quake is from id...

<< Comment #110 @ 23:47 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Anonymous (91.233.249.42)

"100% illuminati

you always had your satanic rituals in the games.. no one will believe so, cuz most are just blind retards who cant even tell a plum from an apple... but you will be missed ;)"

pls explain drinking_soma

<< Comment #153 @ 06:01 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

danstar - Reply to #110

who are you, please explain, anonymous :)

<< Comment #109 @ 23:47 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Anonymous (83.204.179.126)

i wish sometimes the old team of idsoftware makes another fucking blow before i pass out on this earth.

-JC_Danton.

1%

<< Comment #105 @ 22:58 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Vo0

:((((((((((((

<< Comment #106 @ 23:19 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Terbo

The god of all First Person Shooters.

John Carmack created Quake which became more than a game but an engine.

The Quake engine went on to power many games but also helped spawned some of the most important FPS franchises in history... Half Life, Call of Duty, Medal of Honor, Jedi Knight, Star Wars Elite Force... and not to mention the hundreds of game developers who got started making mods with id engines.

He's the Steve Jobs of FPSs....

Good luck in whatever you have planned next John!

7%

<< Comment #164 @ 07:34 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

randomness666 - Reply to #106

What ? Steve Jobs of FPS ?

What bad have carmack ever done to you for insulting him that horribly ?

54%

<< Comment #171 @ 08:43 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

nex1 ' - Reply to #106

I think you are highly overrating the influence of the idtech3 graphic engine on other games: all the games you have mentioned are totally different from quake 3, in every aspect, from the ambientations to the game mechanics; the only thing they shares are a bigger or smaller percentage of the quake graphic engine, heavily modified, expanded (and bettered) to suit those games.

The point is, all of those games could have been made starting from other engines suitables at the time, without big problems.
And no one of those games have been influenced from quake's characteristics aspects.
It can't be said that Quake influenced Call of Duty 1. Or Half Life.

<< Comment #186 @ 12:24 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Weird - Reply to #171

Ye and dos/windows didn't mean anything for the pc market at all either!

<< Comment #213 @ 20:22 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Terbo - Reply to #171

You don't think John Carmack's work had any influence on Half Life or Call of Duty? That's like saying Thomas Edison had no influece on the guys who made the first lamps.

Edited by Terbo at 20:24 CST, 23 November 2013

<< Comment #217 @ 05:00 CST, 24 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By $\0/$ -xinnn- - Reply to #171

It can't be said that Quake influenced Call of Duty 1. Or Half Life.

This is true.
They wouldn't even exist like we know them.

Edited by xin at 06:21 CST, 24 November 2013

<< Comment #107 @ 23:39 CST, 22 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

24

It's a great loss. Carmack is a technical genius. He's probably one of the most intelligent people on Earth.

However, he's not a creative genius. He can no longer help id to success. It's sad to see him go, but this will not affect us in a bad way. I wish him good luck in the future with other projects!

Thank you for all your work, John! Good Game!

Edited by 24 at 23:40 CST, 22 November 2013

5%

<< Comment #132 @ 04:35 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

EKSelenc - Reply to #107

This. While Carmack has always been a technical beast, he's not that kind of leader able to 'resurrect' Quake in current century. Still we all owe him great deal because of Quake engines we've been using for almost 2 decades now.

Edited by EKSelenc at 04:38 CST, 23 November 2013

<< Comment #144 @ 05:32 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

sirax - Reply to #107

'He's probably one of the most intelligent people on Earth'

bitch please

12%

<< Comment #269 @ 04:59 CST, 28 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Rothaarig3 - Reply to #144

obviously you never heared some tech guy /programmer speaking about his work in computing or computer science

try watch a guru like Marshall Kirk McKusick talking about the BSD file system UFS/ZFS and stay awake !
FreeBSD Kernel Internals, Dr. Marshall Kirk McKusick

<< Comment #270 @ 06:27 CST, 28 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

sirax - Reply to #269

yeah I never heard anyone talking about computer science whilst I did my undergraduate and masters degrees in computer science

harosh

<< Comment #273 @ 05:28 CST, 29 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Rothaarig3 - Reply to #270

^ ^

<< Comment #247 @ 02:07 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Badb0y - Reply to #107

i think you hit the nail

<< Comment #111 @ 01:30 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Vig1lante

I really can't believe this is the end of an era, Carmack leaving Id.... I really hope they somehow find a way to get new games and game engines out otherwise Id is doomed

<< Comment #114 @ 02:14 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Whipas

Well this has ruined my day...

<< Comment #124 @ 03:59 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

EmSixTeen

sadfiss.

<< Comment #125 @ 04:00 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

deith

What a sad day for gaming industry, what a great day for humankind!

<< Comment #128 @ 04:24 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

KUND3L

John Carmak is the antichrist.
It is responsible for creating the technology that allows to show in a realistic manner hell on computers.
His game infect the minds of young people who become aggressive, full of violence, rapists.
His departure from ID Software is a sign that God has not abandoned us.

"There will be great earthquakes, and in various places famines and pestilences; there will be terrors and great signs from heaven."
Not ANYMORE !

3%

<< Comment #130 @ 04:29 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

pacmanpl - Reply to #128

rapha is jesus who plays hellish abomination? ]:U

<< Comment #131 @ 04:33 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

nikre

This is not very surprising after ID was acquired. I don't know any details about how Bethesda acquired ID in the first place but that should have limited decision making priorities.
I hope he comes up with better ideas and improves competitive gaming with better computer human interfaces.

side note: i just learnt that the name id was pronounced as "eed" as in id,ego superego.
kinda late.

Edited by nikre at 04:35 CST, 23 November 2013

<< Comment #134 @ 04:40 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

VRED

Great news !! Does it mean no more 5h Keynotes on Qcon ?

<< Comment #139 @ 05:26 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

cha0z_ - Reply to #134

He is genious.. I would listen him not for 5, but for 10 hours.

9%

<< Comment #135 @ 05:00 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

flocks

Well, thanks for everything, Mr. Carmack.

<< Comment #137 @ 05:22 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

evoke

End of an era. Even though it probably won't matter that much in reality. The next Doom/Quake would've sucked anyway.

<< Comment #246 @ 02:05 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Badb0y - Reply to #137

i ll take every doom/quake.

<< Comment #140 @ 05:28 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

zealot

John Carmack ‏@ID_AA_Carmack 14h

I wanted to remain a technical adviser for Id, but it just didn't work out. Probably for the best, as the divided focus was challenging.

hm, weird :(

<< Comment #156 @ 06:15 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Pirx - Reply to #140

well, if he preferred to focus on occulus, rockets or whatever, i guess working with the other programmers at id just got in the way. that's a huge amount of work, not something one can code over a weekend, expert or not.

btw, i miss the fluid, lagless feel of carmack's engines, as most modern games are console ports, with limited tweaking options and movement as if you're skating around.

Edited by Torr Samaho at 06:16 CST, 23 November 2013

<< Comment #201 @ 15:24 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

zealot - Reply to #156

he makes it sound like he got in the way not work, same thing with the official id statement.

<< Comment #245 @ 02:04 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Badb0y - Reply to #201

i wait for the upcoming interviews (maybe in a few months). this will be funny.

<< Comment #142 @ 05:30 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

ddk

Honestly I think all the evidence leads to this being a very positive thing. Carmack pretty much had the biggest influence in creating all of the most important successes of idSoftware, it's fair to say. He was always the all star in the company and the one whose natural intellectual curiousities would spark jaunts into unmapped territory, usually territory he would soon understand every nook and cranny of, whilst simultaneously attempting to push the limits of what is already established.

It's better if he is able to roam free without the shackles, in this case, of an unreasonable obligation to idSoftware for the merit that he has a profound history there. He's honestly a treasure that needs to be shared and his time has important implications-- he has still so much to offer. So that's why I believe it's a great thing.

Thanks Carmack for idtech1 and idtech3 <3

14%

<< Comment #147 @ 05:48 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

sirax - Reply to #142

Carmack was great at squeezing performance from limited hardware, but that became less relevant ages ago.

2012 Doom 3 BFG edition (Year of: Max Payne 3, Mass Effect 3, Far Cry 3 etc)
2011 - Rage (Year of: Skyrim, Arkham City, GTA 4)
2009 - Wolfeinstein (Year of: Arkham Asylum, Call of Duty MW2)
2006 - Orcs Elves (Year of: Half Life 2 Episode 1)

If I ran a gaming company he wouldn't be allowed anywhere near design decisions..

<< Comment #162 @ 07:24 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

gSTRUCTOR ' - Reply to #147

> If I ran a gaming company he wouldn't be allowed anywhere near design decisions..

The last game where Carmack had design decisions was Quake 3 Arena, nuff said.

1%

<< Comment #231 @ 04:03 CST, 25 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Rothaarig3 - Reply to #162

normally i watch the Qcon keynote a 2nd time, but last year ... froget it !

... nuff said ...

Edited by Rothaarig3 at 04:04 CST, 25 November 2013

<< Comment #166 @ 07:43 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Demiurge ' - Reply to #147

It's still relevant, because he cares about latency, feel, and correctness. Every game I try feels slower and unresponsive, and yes, most people don't notice.

<< Comment #187 @ 12:28 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Weird - Reply to #166

I played with a 50ms delayed mouse for about a year.... Didn't notice a thing untill I played on someone else's pc and went OMFG THIS IS SO MUCH BETTER.
If you play with consistent lag you stop noticing it fairly fast.

<< Comment #190 @ 13:09 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

sirax - Reply to #166

I think most people prefer stunning graphics, engrossing gameplay, exciting characters and story lines. All those things missing from Carmack games in the last 12? years :)

Sorry not a fanboy :P

1%

<< Comment #196 @ 14:33 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

!nFerNo - Reply to #142

Why would you omit idtech2?

<< Comment #203 @ 16:24 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Laim - Reply to #196

He played Q3 and then QW, but i don't know if he ever played Q2.

<< Comment #214 @ 20:51 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

gSTRUCTOR ' - Reply to #196

agreed idtech2 made romero delay failatana when he saw how awesome colored lighting was.

<< Comment #149 @ 05:52 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

nex1 '

Edited by nex1 at 05:55 CST, 23 November 2013

<< Comment #181 @ 09:43 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

viaIImaximus - Reply to #149

.

Edited by viaIImaximus at 09:45 CST, 23 November 2013

2%

<< Comment #244 @ 01:57 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Badb0y - Reply to #181

reminds me on the lamps in doom.

Edited by Badb0y at 01:59 CST, 26 November 2013

<< Comment #151 @ 05:55 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

r34Lh4t3

DAMN john ;_;
u FFS better come back if 3d googles have earned enough for doom4, quake 5 SUCCESS

<< Comment #152 @ 05:58 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Rothaarig3

rats leaving the sinking ship ...

<< Comment #159 @ 07:05 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

doped - Reply to #152

did you just call JC a rat??

<< Comment #182 @ 10:16 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

viaIImaximus - Reply to #159

no he called him a sinking ship

2%

<< Comment #268 @ 04:47 CST, 28 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Rothaarig3 - Reply to #159

Metaphor

<< Comment #274 @ 07:05 CST, 29 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

doped - Reply to #268

i know, but you still called creator of quake a rat. You don't see what im getting at?

<< Comment #275 @ 08:57 CST, 29 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Rothaarig3 - Reply to #274

nope, just your imagine ...

<< Comment #228 @ 23:02 CST, 24 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

ia - Reply to #152

More like if you're not he captain you don't have to go down with the ship.

<< Comment #230 @ 03:56 CST, 25 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Rothaarig3 - Reply to #228

he's the cptain of the Costa Concordia lol

<< Comment #238 @ 23:55 CST, 25 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

ia - Reply to #230

no idea what that is

<< Comment #255 @ 04:28 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

viaIImaximus - Reply to #238

u just missed a good joke tho

<< Comment #256 @ 05:58 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Rothaarig3 - Reply to #238

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Costa_Concordia#..._incidents

<< Comment #243 @ 01:52 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Badb0y - Reply to #152

the metapher of a ship is very strong, but maybe not accurate for the situation.

<< Comment #161 @ 07:20 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

frs

really cant say that i care, id hasnt done anything in over a decade that i cared about

Edited by frs at 07:21 CST, 23 November 2013

<< Comment #242 @ 01:47 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Badb0y - Reply to #161

:( rage and id tech5, bfg, mobile games

<< Comment #263 @ 10:33 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Rothaarig3 - Reply to #242

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Id_Tech_5#Games_using_id_Tech_5

watt ne totgeburt ...

<< Comment #163 @ 07:30 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

lolograde

This probably GOOD news for Quake. JC often said things that were anti-hardcore gaming. I think i remember him saying anything above 60fps was pointless and only for hardcore players. He wanted to make more mainstream games targeted at console gamers. No doubt he's a brilliant guy, but my guess is we will see more emphasis on established franchises in the right ways with all the shake ups at id recently.

<< Comment #168 @ 08:19 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

nemecel - Reply to #163

He has been biging up the pro players on Quakecons and he is one of the main supporters of low latency gaming (something inherently hardcore)

<< Comment #191 @ 13:10 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

myT - Reply to #163

His point was that the jump from 30fps to 60fps rendering was a big deal in perceived smoothness while the jump from 60 to 120 wasn't as big a deal when all input latencies were already low. RAGE runs at 60Hz but feels very responsive.

3%

<< Comment #241 @ 01:45 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Badb0y - Reply to #191

yeah, i think pakalolo got it wrong.

in the rage phase, jc was talking about console and pc problems in development. at first i thought a few times, he bashes pc gaming when talking about console gaming. but he just adressed different probs on two platforms.

<< Comment #172 @ 09:04 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Qvist

What a legend, without him we would likely not even know how awesome competitive FPS-games can be.

<< Comment #173 @ 09:14 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

ACiDC0re

omg, the end of an era :/

<< Comment #192 @ 13:36 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

PsY^

John Carmack

The reason we have a life. He is the source of life.
Milestone for further development in 3d gaming history.
Wolfenstein 3D, Doom,Hexen, Quake I-III

What can I say, without you, my life would have been meaningless.

I owe you everything, and praise you like a god.

id - John Carmack <3

3%

<< Comment #207 @ 17:04 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

PYTON - Reply to #192

So true. I spent more then half of my life playing Quake. :P

<< Comment #194 @ 13:59 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Vig1lante

To anyone that usually watches Carmack's keynote at QuakeCon every year. He did a tweet earlier regarding his QuakeCon keynotes.

If they don't want me to talk on stage at Quakecon next year, we'll just have to fill up the lobby like the old days. :-)

This should be news for anybody who likes watching his annual keynotes every QuakeCon year

Edited by Vig1lante at 13:59 CST, 23 November 2013

10%

<< Comment #195 @ 14:22 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

skulp - Reply to #194

that's cool to know :D!

<< Comment #199 @ 15:01 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Anonymous (50.7.78.90)

I suspect he also invented the internet.

<< Comment #204 @ 16:31 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

viaIImaximus - Reply to #199

and toilet paper

<< Comment #205 @ 16:35 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

stuntz - Reply to #204

and bunnyhopping

<< Comment #209 @ 17:30 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Something - Reply to #205

Actually he wanted rid of strafe jumping.

<< Comment #211 @ 17:49 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

c3rb - Reply to #209

And the double jump in Quake2 is actually caused by a bug in the physics engine.

Edited by c3rb at 06:27 CST, 24 November 2013

<< Comment #215 @ 21:20 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

amalik - Reply to #209

true. If you look in the design documents for Quake3 he was very much against it. That's also why Q3test originally had it disabled, until negative response from players shifted id's opinion.

<< Comment #222 @ 09:51 CST, 24 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

kodisha - Reply to #215

this is really interesting.

I'm really interested in strafe jumping and other movement "features" of quake engines. Some people take it for granted, or underestimate importance of it, but i think that is one of key features that makes quake gameplay so interesting.

Also i see a reason why CS disabled it, they wanted more realistic experience, and they wanted to emphasise positioning/tactics over movement.

I didn't play much of UT and other games and i wonder whats the level of strafe jumping there. Also i wonder which other games out there use the same/similar system and where that kind of movement has same weight as in quake (only one i know and tried for few days is warsow)

For sceptics out there, imagine how boring the quake will be if you had to WALK to capture flag, on, lets say, Japansese Castles :D

Edited by kodisha at 09:51 CST, 24 November 2013

<< Comment #224 @ 12:19 CST, 24 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

ybl - Reply to #222

yup, what a weird misinterpretation this is. q3 died, while cpm had/s a solid playerbase. i still wonder, why the ql staff is not understanding this. they should push the game into this direction (leave default ql as it is, but add mucccchhhh more contend for cpm), to save ql

<< Comment #225 @ 12:22 CST, 24 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Nalipotanka - Reply to #224

CPM wont save QL. It will alienate it even more...People struggle with basics of VQ and you think adding mroe CPM content will help? :/

Edited by Nalipotanka at 12:24 CST, 24 November 2013

4%

<< Comment #233 @ 09:33 CST, 25 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

xero- ' - Reply to #225

That's a good point, and this may seem like a bit of a tangent, but if relatively complicated games (TF2, DoTA 2, LoL) can become so popular, I don't think the complexity (i.e. Quake is too complicated/old) issue holds any footing. What it has come down to is poor execution, a lack of foresight with respect to UI and other assets, no respect for the current realities of the internet-gaming, poor marketing, and a lack of a dedicated staff.

9%

<< Comment #235 @ 13:25 CST, 25 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

cx ' - Reply to #225

cpm is an extension of the gameplay, it adds more depth, it doesnt make it more complicated for new players, since they can still play quake more or less normally as before ... advanced players gonna annihilate them with or without cpm physics ... doesnt make a difference in the end

<< Comment #208 @ 17:11 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Yellack

:/

<< Comment #210 @ 17:36 CST, 23 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

ybl

i havent played much other games besides quake the last years. was rage looking so much better then crysis 3... and if or if not, the games dont interest me at all. maybe a game with good physix would be nice, but this seems to be very hard to do.

tl,dr: quake live good enough 4 me

<< Comment #216 @ 03:48 CST, 24 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

YoJJi

God will no more creat video games , so sad .

7%

<< Comment #221 @ 08:22 CST, 24 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

CMSS

bye john :(

<< Comment #226 @ 14:23 CST, 24 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

sleepii

idtech5 engine looks shit compared to other games out there today. look at the bf4, cod, crysis engines. just doesn't even matter. id is like years behind.

<< Comment #264 @ 10:36 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Rothaarig3 - Reply to #226

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Id_Tech_5#Games_using_id_Tech_5

2%

<< Comment #227 @ 23:01 CST, 24 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

ia

Looking forward to playing Quake at 120fps on the Occulus Rift.

<< Comment #234 @ 11:39 CST, 25 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Anonymous (82.145.211.65)

RAGEQUIT NOOB

<< Comment #237 @ 21:46 CST, 25 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Anonymous (206.167.182.249)

This seem like a good time to suggest reading the book Masters of Doom. It was written in 2003 and it follows Carmack and Romero from their childhood up to the release of Doom 3. I'm not a big reader but I couldn't put this book down!

14%

<< Comment #240 @ 01:36 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Badb0y - Reply to #237

good written book. its like the author was standing in the room and saw it all.

<< Comment #258 @ 07:50 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

gSTRUCTOR ' - Reply to #237

Awesome book.

<< Comment #239 @ 01:33 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By

Badb0y

it would get to long to say what i think and believe. just this.

the sale to bethesda was needed to finance rage and save the future of the studio.

id can do good games. they only need 25% of strength and ideas that the old games had and their fine.

<< Comment #254 @ 03:15 CST, 26 November 2013 >>

(Link, Reply)

By