Both are great gamers and it is very hard to decide. Went with fatal1ty in the end.

Me too. I think what annoys a lot of people about fatal1ty is that he doesn't out-aim the opponent but plays sound, doesn't take unnecessary risks, almost always +backs to secure a lead and so on. It must be really frustrating to meet him in a competition, and that's why top players seem to dislike him.

I think most people are more impressed by aim, like when unKind came. Suddenly everyone held him as #1 for all time because it looked so impressive. But I doubt unKind will even be nominated in this competition. Why? Because he hasn't proven himself in as many competitions as fatal1ty, ZeRo4 et al.

I think it takes a lot of balls to go pro, especially when not playing in a great team. Your own quality of play is what decides your income, nothing else. If he'd been a normal player, when arrangers abandoned Q3 duelling, it had been over. But instead he moved his game over to other FPS's. That just shows how solid his game is and how much he wants to stay a pro-gamer.

He sponsors his own e-sports team, arranges tournaments, and yeah, he sells products with fatal1ty logos on'em. The last idea he could've shoved :) but he's putting some money back in the scene. I see him as a great guy, even tho his promoters saying he's "champion of the world waah" will make people hate him.

fatal1ty is the guy who made me stick with Q3 and start duelling, when I could just have played a few more FFA games :) and then switch to the next game that looked good.

fatality

It will be a very dramatic fight imo, 5% difference max :)

huh. i guess at least 70% will vote for fatality.

fatality imo

I think that fata1ty will win this one ....and others too ; ) he is the best pro-gamer in my opinion :*

Most well known, not necessarilly the most skilled.

yes i my opinion -> Fatality will win...

Argh.. What about the strange message i got when i voted? :(

Creating some tension I guess :)

GitzZz. Because I play UT!

it is said : "Greatest Gamer of all Time"
not : "the guy who play my game"
...

UT takes more skill
start flames... now

FLAME FLAME!!1! >:O

erm wait... you're actually right o_O

Nah, seriously they're both great gamers just GitzZz is a bit greater imo. :]

Yes, and I'm sure that GitzZz is the "Greatest Gamer of all Time". At least I rate him higher than Fata.

Now you see how misunderstood is this poll....

fatality must be the 1st

POLOS!

THRESH! *MOAN WHINE*

GitzZz has won every international tournament he competed in, - thats just amazing

I voted on him because of that... If he's there, no one else wins :>

only @ lan, he didnt win the online esreality tourney :)

still voted gitzzz

for one that he wins wherever he is, his playstyle is fresh and entertaining, his achievements are great, he stays modest. now thats being professional

I wouldn't say playing a purely hitscan based game is very creative and refreshing though...

theres not really a difference in gitzzz and fatal1ty when it comes to hitscan usage
gitzzz plays more creative tho, and makes nicer combo's etc :)

I haven't followed UT2k3 so I wouldn't know the difference between the two players there. I'd say Gitzzz' playing style in UT however wasn't quite creative, playing almost solely sniper/mini/pulse shows you can aim well, not that you're the most creative in minds

tbh i liked gitzZz playing style in UT. Especially on deck where he just dominated his opponents. The perfect timing this guy had was just scary on deck.

in ut2k3 he played alot with bio in the beginning :P, that was pretty creative :P

uncreative weaponusage doesnt make an uncreative playingstyle

his prediction for instance was uber (deck)

like the demo vs evenflow on tempest vmuch too

Fat been playing on a top level in many games, but he hassnt dominated one game as much as gitzz did. I got for gitz on this one.

I agree that GitzZz has a nice domination going, Fatal1ty did a way better job promoting e-sports tho.

he promoted himself, not esports

your wrong ;)

You're *

idd :f

Nevertheless imo they're both great gamers due to their great efforts national AND international.

Still my vote goes to GitzZz, coz he proved additional to that to be the more skilled gamer. :E

He promoted himself which promoted esports. He seems to have a better attitude than alot of players which makes for good interviews.

yeah, I love to read interviews about people that love to brag about themselves.

He does talk about his acheivments yeh, but he seems a nicer guy than alot of other gamers, who seem much more arrogant, ie. when they moan saying stuff like 'ffs' 'luck' etc.

you're a bit right there, but I still don't think fatality was aiming for the promotion of esports, he was aiming for his own promotion. consequently, it promoted esports.

And?

and I wasn't talking to you?

and?

If you don't think Fat whines about luck, then I feel sorry for you.

rofl, what a stupid comment. Why would you feel sorry for me for not knowing about if he whines or not? I just said that i get that impression from his interviews, at least compared to some other players.

This is about the best gamer though..

It's about the greatest gamer. I've already explained what makes a great gamer in my book, if domination or medal count is enough for you, that's fine with me too.

I guess it all depends on your values.

I chose fat because of all his other achievements as a gamer, not how well he actually done. The fact that he has his own product lines, appeared on countless TV shows, even ones almost totally dedicated to him, been able to be at the top in multiple games etc, and yes he spent a lot of time promoting and progressing e-sports.

as far as i know gitz only plays and does nothing else. even if he was never beaten, i would still vote for fat.

thats why you should vote for Gitzzz, the poll is after all "greatest gamer" and not "businessman" :)
and is there anything greater than winning every tournament entered?

to me a gamer is more than someone who just sits infront of computer all day playing and doing nothing else. there are other qualities that make the person a better 'gamer; in my eyes

thats all Gitzzz, no 12h/day praccy needed unlike someone :)

So you think a great gamer would have to go out and promote E-Sports?

Accepting interviews, supplying demos for others to learn from, writing guides and other contributions to the community are achievements which separate great gamers from good gamers who just appear once or twice a year to dominate in a tourney. Imho.

Hmm there is plenty of demos and interviews of GitzZz :P

not neccessarly that, but I think a good gamer has to do things other than just playing (i mentioned several things up there, not just that one). Theres lots of other things that could also be done which in my eyes set a gamer apart from the rest.

finally you have to register to vote.

fatality because gitzz is german ;)

Do you honestly believe thats funny?

i do now thanx :)

OLOLO YUO WOULD BE TEH FUNNEH BUT YUO ARE AUSTRALIAN SO YUO NO FUNNEH OLOLOL!!1$#"$#

SOMECOUNTRY > AUSTRALIA!!!!111$%#$

There, another extremelly funny statement :)

Finally you see things my way!

it's gotta be fatal1ty... xD

yep fatal1ty hes a nice guy too :p

To hard to chose one imho, so I pick neither :)

fatal1ty all the way

gitzz cuz he iz zee german

bound to be fat but my vote goes to gitzz - fat doesn't seem to have the staying power - gets off to a good start but then people catch up and overtake him - prolly cos noone else devotes the hours that he does (or claims to) - anyway he comes across as an arrogant sob :)

looks like that, while Gitzzz is allaround very nice and humble guy

No offense but i dont think we know either of the players so u cant judge on personalitys its truely gotta be game play! Good luck to them both :)

heh - true - most american's come across as arrogant sob's :)

first point stands though - fat gets out when the competition hots up - gitzz has dominated his game - and it's sequels - over all comers

Which is why he chose to play CS?
Fatal1ty goes where the money and the competition is. As long as games are still pretty similar, I think it's the multi-gamers who practice a lot that will make e-sports big. As Fatal1ty has shown.

Well thats a very good point... still both of them r great players..!!
My vote goes to gitzzz..!! Gl

FATAL1TY! :D

A very tough call. Fatality won almost everything there was to win in 2000, he’s become very, very popular and used that popularity very well. He’s made FPS gaming a job for himself and I have to say I admire his attitude towards his job (has he ever said no to an interview offer?). On the downside, his status from ‘god’ in 2000 has deteriorated to ‘a very good’ player in 2001, 2002 and 2003 (none of these years he could call successful really).

On the other side there’s GitzZz who has made a huge impact on the whole gaming community – he has made UT a respected game and he’s become a role model for many, many gamers. Talent-wise, I think GitzZz is as good as it gets in gaming (he won every international tournament he entered, including 2 WCG’s and ESWC). He’s also a great person – very modest and he I know beyond any doubt that he would rather lose to a great player than win an easy $20,000.

For that reason, I vote for GitzZz, the better gamer.

agree... gitzz is on another level...

Hey, now I don't have to post

Skill-wise I'm on the same page as you. But some of the criticisms about Fat promoting himself are extremely shallow. Yes, Thresh pioneered professional gaming, but it was Fatal1ty that changed the market enough to get himself employed in the sector.

GitzZz is a great gamer, no doubt, but it's Fatal1ty's media flair that has given e-sports the face it now has. Fat is and has been gaming's ambassador to the real world.

No actually, "the real world" in gaming-terms is korea, and fat is nowhere near korea :P

That's what I mean. Korea is on a whole other level. Fatal1ty's been bringing an ounce of that craze over to America and the western world. And for that I don't think we can be anything but thankful.

Dunno really... because in real life in polish daily press I twice readed about "Christian" winning "Computer Games Olympic", and only once saw "Jonathan" in article about modern games (mentioned about cash he earned).

European newspaper, American player - 2+2...

Fatality - Because he's worth it.

hmm fatag1tz.

now you attempt for pluses sucks :(

it wasnt a 'search for a plus'. i was mearly pointing out how i didnt know who to vote for. great.

sorry sir :(

have to go with fat for the fact he's made progaming a mroe widely known phenomena :>

This poll is about the "greatest gamer ever", this means the person who "has achieved the most over alot of games" and not about who promoted gaming the best or who is a better gamer for a particular game. Between these two, fat has achieved the most over a wide number of games than gitzz, so my vote goes to fat.

Well the advantage isn't that significant.

Fat: Q3, AVP, UT2k3
Gitz: UT, UT2k3.

And Gitzzz completely dominated those 2 games, while fat didn't. (AvP? lol)

fat has done really well in QW and CS as well.

actually what do you call "done well"?
not playing one match for your team at the cpl in cs? i dont know about qw, but i doubt that he made an impact there. :)

no doubt about fatality's qualities anyways. but for me personally gitzzz is the greater gamer and the greater rolemodel :)

He's played CS at an earlier event as well. I don't remember when it was, but I think it was in late 2001. His team placed 6th or something. He also placed really well in the CPL anniversary QW tournament a couple of years ago.

Give me a break with UT2003 and AvP2.

Basically all GitzZz has going for him too, you know.

The competition title is "Greatest Gamer Of All Times" and not "Greatest E-Sports Promoter of all times" but maybe we should define first what a gamer is. In my opinion it is more about his achievements on playing, not on promotion nevertheless it is a great accomplishment, too.

Sorry should be an answer to #27. btw my vote goes for gitzZz and fat :)

Since being a great gamer is not only about skill, but your attitude and contribution to the game, GitzZz gets my vote.

I'm had to go for Gitzz on this one, simply because he's held on at the top while the skill level slowly rose (as it always does with time), whereas fatal1ty only really dominates games at the beginning.

Has to be Gitzzz...

fatality

Cool, you cant look at peoples votes anymore, so noone will know i voted for fat!

yeah, they'll be really disappointed with that..

no doubt - Gitzzz (the godlike one)
nobody else has such dominance...

gitz for me, he dominated the ut scene in duel for such a long time

nice that you need registration now... Should get a lot less votes from SK fanboys

...and more votes from equally narrow-minded quake fanboys. whatever.

didn't you learn anything from the previous votes ?

do i look like your mirror?

I guess that answered my question. Btw I sure don't hope my mirror looks like you.

If people would learn that Schroet isn't all bad. Opening it up now would see that they've linked to this page, telling people to vote even in this poll. If anything, I think they should eb thanked, since the poll is really a publicity stunt by ESR - so ESR won't always be 95% Quakers, 2% CSers and 3% random idiots (like me).

It's called closing the door once the horse has bolted.

Changing the eligible-to-vote demographic mid-contest is as big a mistake as letting hordes of open proxy bashers play ball in the first place.

GitzZz. My vote had nothing to do with him being part of SK as I'm sure many will feel the same.

that's something that isn't worth mentioning

GitzZz

:o

gitzzz

nice to have to be registered...but not that its not allowed to see the result ;) in a way its good coz u will not be attract in the ease way in voting for the lead
GitzZz to his domination , to the fact that he has the best aim ever seen in ut and maybe in some other game, and due to the fact that its a very simple guy, not as fatality

6 CPLS CAN YOUR MOUSEPAD SAY THAT


FAT POLO

Wanna look phat at your next tourney? Hop your fragging self into a fatpolo that the pros fear.

FAT BEANIE

Are you a player or a playa? That's what you have to ask yourself when you step in with the big boyz.

THE SLOGANS ARE REASON ENOUGH YOU HAVE TO VOTE THE FATAL ONE

gitzZz cos he was looking at some Q3 in the ESWC movie

lol :P

truthfully, did you vote if so who? :)

A good reason not to vote for Fat :
Just look at his car's paintjob.

it came like this when he won an AvP tournament, duh

It is still ugly.

GitzZz, because I am a UT player and have played against him in his prime. The result was not good for my self-esteem :)

To minus ? :P
One of our (polish) players played against him at PGCH 2k2 and... well... actually... khem... :PPP

i cant really judge... but for some reason i thought it might be gitzzz and voted that way....

america > germany .....

pie > non-pie

Embroglio > carmac

Pussy > ass

penis > tits

gold cockring > steel cockring

pink tarzan vibrator > green hulk vibrator

BF1942 > Quake. Flame below.

fatal

" the only big name in FPS games who has won every international tournament he competed in, something even Fatal1ty in his prime could not achieve"

ROFL, yea FOUR lans and when you consider the competition the prague event was hardly on the same scale as winning a CPL. He might not have had the opportunity to attend more LANs but it's difficult to compare a game like Quake 3 where the competition is unbelievable and there are a lot of events to someone who plays UT which has a smaller 1v1 scene and less LANs.

Oh and also clearly GitzZz couldn't go to WCG/ECG for reasons beyond his control but he still didn't attent CXG/CPL when I'm pretty sure SK would have paid his expenses. Whether he went because he didn't feel like playing or w/e is irrelevant, you can't compare someone who has been in 4 events and won them all with someone who has been in like 30 events and won quite a few :)

Well apparently Fat didn't do quite as well as in UT's "smaller" 1v1 scene as he did in Quake 3's "Unbelievable Competition". And you have to remember 2 of Gitz's wins are WCG so it's like those are "easy" wins.

lol forget it dude, he doesn't even know what he's talking about. the competition of the CPLs that fatality won are far from close to the competition that gitzzz faced at the tournaments he competed. btw, ESCW UT2003 = gitzz 1st place, fatality 5th or summin?

...

you're prolly right. I knew zulg was 2nd but didn't know the exat place of fat.

wasn't that gitzzz/lotus/zulg/fat ?

1. gitzzz
2. zulg (beaten by gitzzz)
3. fat (beaten by zulg)
4. solo


afaik ;)

4. The Great Lotus ;)

Fat has my vote, he is amazingly talented and he gave up a more standard and so called serious life because of gaming.

Whether it really pays off it reamins to be seen, although it's something that puts him above gitzz.

I agree. Fatal1ty is the icon of dedication in gaming. He started e-sports as a viable career option for some people, in America and Europe at least. I think that deserves some credit...

atleast I had 3 out of 4 :f

If you say so boss, I guess there are only two possibilities in any situation...

Don't start the q3>ut bs. UT never had a smaller 1on1 scene than q3. The top50 1on1 UT players were equivalent to the top50 q3'ers, each in their scene. Less LANs you say ? Ignorant. In germany and holland there were LANs top players and clans attended atleast every other weekend, hence especially ocrana's amazingly long LAN tournament record. Most top UT players played only on LAN. Why ? Because they didn't have to play online when there were lan events everywhere, more effective practise.

If you are implying like GitzZz was the only great player because nobody else really played, let me tell you this, just a small example. Correct me if I'm wrong anyone, but in a qualifier a great player -br3z- did 100% accuracy with sniper. ALL DAMN SHOTS. And still he LOST the game. That's fucking amazing if you ask me, also considering the high ROF and the hitboxes being screwed up. Ever heard of a q3 player that hit 100% rail in an important game under pressure?

Oh and yea, AvP had damn fierce competition, I bet the whole fucking CPL were attending.

depends how many shots he gave though to know if that's impressive or not..


anyway I remember vipere1 doing 80+% rail vs polosatiy at a LanArena I think, so yeah it's not 100% but still

Well since it's Br3z so it's probably a lot. :) UT Sniper has a high firing rate.

"If you are implying like GitzZz was the only great player because nobody else really played"

You pulled that clean out of your own ass where your head appears to be so don't let anything I say get in the way of your ranting =]

That's what I said because you said that basically UT had no competition which is totally wrong.

And please don't play with words as you make yourself look stupid as usual.

"you said that basically UT had no competition which is totally wrong."

Feel free to quote any sentence where I said that...you'll find none exist :)

Look; I don't read your boring posts 15 times to completely understand what your non-existant point is.

You didn't read it once properly. Not only that but you replied 3 times to a post that apparently wasn't even worth your time. Congratulations: you're a retard. Feel free to ring your mum and dad who always figured you'd end up as a little imbecile - you've made the bigtime now! :D

You've just shown in every post that you can't be taken seriously. But what's your point ? You had absolutely no clue what you were talking about in the first place. Others have proved that long time ago.

So then stop inventing the wheel idiot :)

LOL... to me your posts are almost always pure entertainment to read.. you seem SO angry its incredible.

I voted fat btw.

Yes, the competition in Q3 was so unbelieveable, that the god of gods in Q3 got beaten by players who came from UT how many times? Six. And those UT players won the events the Q3 god could not win.

Clearly, GitzZz didn't got to CXG/CPL because he has got self-respect. Money is not that important for him. GitzZz dominated for three years in his games, Fatality dominated in one game, for one year.

"that the god of gods in Q3 got beaten by players who came from UT how many times?"

In which game? Last I checked it wasn't so many years ago the 400 metres world champion beat the 100 metres world champion at the 200 metres :)

Feel free to attribute some other stuff I didn't say to me though, get it all off your chest michael you angry young Polish man =]

it's difficult to compare a game like Quake 3 where the competition is unbelievable and there are a lot of events to someone who plays UT

If you think that I am angry, you value yourself too highly.

Hehe

Just "lols" from your knowledge about UT :P

both great icons but got to go with fatal1ty

My vote goes to GitzZz.
He wasn't like other proplayers who just rejected a duel challenge, gitzzz gave me an explanation why he didn't want to play ;D

As it was already mentioned, Gitzzz dominated UT since ut1 and I guess he'll be dominating in UT2k4 while fatal1ty kept changing games without achieving much (well, in q3 he was the greatest for some time, but in ut2k3 got 3rd place @ eswc and lost in wcg2003 qualification. sry if I don't know about smaller competitions ;P).

fatal1ty !!!!!

Looks to be a great match, I don't play UT myself but know like all games there is a strong community built around the elite hardcore gamers.

My only question is will there be a Half-Life DM/AG play off? I know a few super elite monkeys never seen on the pro front that I know would walk over any competition put forward to face them, shame the CPL WC isn't held in the UK as well as the US.

my money is on Gitzzz you can't beat a deadicated player who rules at one game but credit must go to Fatal1ty after all takes a lot of skill to own in multi-games

GitzZz..

GitzZz

at last registration needed! that should be made at the begining not now.

Unfortunately, noone can be told what the Matrix is.

the matrix is a good excuse for carrie anne moss to wear tight PVC clothing! $$

Cha-ching!

$_$

Well i have voted fatal because i now him better than grizz and i have to be plain with you I DON'T LIKE GERMANS

but i think Fatality is to comercial player ...

GitzZz for me , I have never been more impressed by any other gamer - SkillzZz

Tough call... both guys are icons, both guys dominated their primary game. fat managed to spread out a bit more than Gitzzz, but then again Gitzzz was untouchable during his entire reign of many years, and I do mean f*cking untouchable.

It's a very tough call but I've seen firsthand what this guy can do. fat was a top-of-the-top player in Q3, but there's a world of difference between Gitzzz and the nr2 in UT/UT2k3.

totally agree

now the poll is still fucked because the quakers will have it easy now

nope

Gotta go with GitzZz, he's so ugly he deserves to win something in life, ironically it being a game which he doesn't actually have to be "seen" playing, lol.

Yeah, it's sad that he's placed next to the Brad Pitt of gaming. Must have a large impact on the vote :(

Yeah, Quakers and hunks like Fat. They just can't resist.

shut up.

fat all the way

This is a very tough choice, but I voted fat in the end. He's an icon for FPS gaming (hrm, Gitzzz isnt?). Gah!

Has GitzZz ever faced fatal1ty in UT2k3?

...

Nope. It was zulg-fat and GitzZz-Lotus in the semis.

I think he meant the overall standings.

Yeah, that's right; it would be nice to see a demo between the two, though. :)

I saw both of their practice games.

no zulg denied this on eswc :(

bad zulg!! ;)

gitz - the real deal. both as player and as a person.

I cant stand Fat's consistent "i wanna do interviews so i can say im an athlete and the tiger woods of gaming" ramling. I realise he's selling himself (lol), but he still sounds like a dork when he behaves like that to me :)

Possibly the most difficult decision of this entire poll. Eventually went with Fat.

What can I say, I'm a fan :)

fat cos of what he has done for the esports scene in general

It's a very hard thing to choose between these Both great gamers.
Fatality is probably the most famous... but GitzZz is the more impressive UT player i've ever seen.

So, i vote GitzZz

Fat, he is a multi gamer, its the best pro-gamer. Nobody has played more games, been good at them as he has.

gitz coz
..
after i've watched MTV show with fatality i was amazed how egocentric this man can be...
i mean, shouting after a win, pretending to be better than others in all aspect.. sorry fat.. but kiss my ass with that attitude .. redneck :F

on the other hand gitz is idd really nice person
+ his great aim / camping / tactic that made him really unbetable in ut (spec deck) is something i personaly admire...

so gitz imo... \o/

flame me =/

Yeah, my god how lame was that shouting? I mean, it's only 10000 dollars where you're playing for.

the dutchie is right, its just 10k nothing really, fat should just shut the fuck up and walk away with it without having any bit of enthusiasm whatsoever! Also the the match he won was pretty shit and newb like, just a CPL final

OMG. How dare he actually be happy when winning the equivalent of 50% of a normal person's yearly wage thanks to one match?! What a stuck-up asshole. I'd never shout if I won 10,000 US dollars...

go gitzzz tbh!

My vote goes for gitz

wouldnt it be nice to add some extra info on the players for round 2 ? I mean, ok from the comments a lot of stuff is being said.....

Very hard choice.. but if gitzz and fatal1ty would face eachother in a ut2k3 tourney... Gitzz would win i think.

Fatal1ty is obviously has a bigger name and stands out from other gamers because of his offensive self-promoting strategy (and his accomplishments). But it's damn hard to ignore gitzz domination of UT/UT2k3 (the titles speak for themselves)...

I'll have to go with... gitzz... he's a master when it comes to the art of FPS gaming.

yeah and if gitzz met fatality in a Q3 match guess who would get his ass wh00ped ?

PS : I didnt mean to [+], I wanted to click on reply :|

Then again, Gitzzz didn't play Q3 competitively while fat did play UT2k3.
That's no excuse, but you can't make that comparison like you just did.

lol of course you can, idiot.

UT2k3 is UT, just tarted up with some nice graphics.

So if your a good UT player you can easily make the switch over to UT2K3 and be instantly good. Obviously gitzzz relied pretty much on that, where as fatality had to learn EVERYTHING, from those pussy jumps you got in UT and how to use that sludge gun properly.

Now, if gitzzz attempted to play q3 competitively in the same time as fat did in ut2k3 he would get his ass wiped so badly he'll have baby bum rash for life.

And it's true.

Also, the UT and UT2K3 wasn't anywhere near as big as Q3 in terms of competitiveness.

/rant over

UT2K3 is UT? :D

glad to see you don't have the faintest clue what you're talking about :>

I THINKS UT PALYERS HAVE 20 CM PENISES AND Q3 PLAYAS ONLY HAVES 10 CM PENISES!!111 OK??????

OH BY TEH WAYS: Q1 IS JUST LIKE Q3!!! JUTS LOTS MORE GRAPHIXS!!!! TWEAKS!!!! UC?????



Seriously, you rock, so does epic, fat, trash food and mark rein, its a world of r0x0rage, uc? :)

lol

lolz

People like you keep stereotypes intact. Simpleton.

So I see that you never played UT :P

that was just to prove that fat was an OVERALL better game than gitzz

gitzz is UT/UT2K3 (which are not very different I assume...)
while fat can play Q3/AVP/UT2K3 and surely is a better CS player than Gitzz

You assume way too much....
People that don't play UT always assume that they are the same game but UT and UT2k3 are 2 very difference games. Just think of the difference between Quake 2 and Quake 3.

UT2k3 isn't a lot more different from Q3 than it is from UT. Just because the weapons look like the old ones doesn't mean that the they're the same game.
Weapon balance has changed considerably, the aiming style has changed, the maps were different, armor management changed enormously, weapon switching was about 4x faster.

Take it from someone who played all three games. In fact, if I really felt like it I could name just as many similarities between Q3 and UT2k3 as I could for UT and UT2k3. However, I won't do that because I know some ignorant ass (not referring to you) will come up with the fact that the movement looks more like UT and then suddenly forgets all the other aspects of gameplay.

But to answer your question, UT2k3 is not that very similar to UT. Both games are fps's yeah, if that's what you mean ;p

Yes, fat would most likely win a q3 match but as reaper said, gitzzz hasnt played q3 while fat has played ut2k3. Sure fat has won several CPL tournaments. But in my opinion WCG/ESWC is a more international tournament than CPL making them more prestigeous.

I'm not saying that fatal1ty is a bad player, he really deserves one of the top 3 spots in this contest (for many reasons other than just his playing). I'm just saying that gitzzz has something special that fatal1ty doesn't have. Although I can't put my finger on it.

fat 4 me :(

Fattyboy gets my vote, he really is the best allround top gamer today, with impressive ratings in several tournaments and games.
If Gitzzz had put the effort to conquer other games, I am sure he would be able to even beat fatal1ty's track record, and even though he infact is unbeaten in ut, i still feel that fat actually is the best gamer today over all.

Remember that these guys play and actually thrive at a level that 80% of this site can only dream of achieving.
With fat actually placing 3rd in ESWC (which, if we are honest here, really had all the top dogs in one batch), proves to me that he is really something special in gaming.

Sorry gtz, no offence. Counquer a few other games and you'll be the king of gaming, no question about it, and you can do it if you want to imo.

More like 98%

I definitely agree that fat was more succesful at 'more' games, but then again he only 'conquered' as many games that mattered as Gitzzz did (Q3 & UT2k3 vs UT & UT2k3).
He owned AvP but that's hardly comparable, and I'm guessing about his CS adventure but that wasn't of the same scope either.

Still, fat's more of a multi-gamer than Gitzzz, that's true.

Fat's the Western equivalent of the Korean gamers. For god's sake, he's been on MTV....

Which is relevant to my post in... which way... exactly?

It will remain a mystery forever.
....
Mistype perhaps?

fat tbh

fataaaaalllll :D

GitzZz.

His Deck 16 performences are just awesome

Gitzz .
i heard he beat fat in practice match at eswc :)

polos is best, i vote polos.

POLOS, WE ARE WITH U
WITH LOVE FROM RUSSIA!!!

POLOS IS RULEZ

ROFL

rofl

ROFL, so you cool dood.

gitzzz

gItZz!

GitzZz's got my vote - reasons have been named by many others before me ;)

This should've been the final imo. :\

GitzZz!
Fat did well to promote himself MAINLY because of his business skills - that doesn't make him the better gamer!

GitzZz!!! :D

I cant choose, therefore I do not vote. I would say GitzZz cuz of the noise Fatal1ty makes when he wins. Or Fatal1ty because hes achieved more.

You mean the "WOHOOOO!! YEAH, that's what I'm talking about!!" stuff ?

More the hunking sound he makes when he breaths heavily inbetween all the shouting

fatman

fatal1ty, no doubt...

"as far as i know gitz only plays and does nothing else. even if he was never beaten, i would still vote for fat."

Because GitzZz is passionate about the game, He plays for the competition. Fatal1ty is in it for the money. He promotes e-sports because it makes him money.

Fatal1ty didnt move to CS to try and be the best, he switched to CS because the community is so much larger, so theres more people to buy his products etc.

but fatal1ty is a dueler i he never be a good teamplayer and CS player

I just remembered that somebody says that gitz while playn TDM have his back allways faced to the walls :) Remembered when joined shuuk-aAa forces in CTF placed him in highest point of map with sniper rifle ;PPP

IMHO Tresh is the best player, but he is gone ;( so, no pretenders here $(

....fatality even was owned by polos--->...Gitz is better.and he won every tornament he played....fatality is a noob who is trainig 12 hours a day....and his skill =0...tried in CS but hi is not enouth skilled to play CS good....

Tresh was the best player may be 8 years ago....

Actually Thresh played till 1999/2000, The last event that he played at was Quakeadelica (or htf u spell it).
From what i know he didn't lose one game in any q2 event. He did however lose 2 maps. But its still 4 years so long time ago anyway.

both of them are big names in e-sports, but i vote for GitzZz, i think he is much more skilled (just my opinion of course :))

1. UT is way to homo-erotic
2. Fat has a tiger
3. Smurfs are blue

therefore i vote for myself

erthjern

may the "greatest" here win... GitzZz imo!

SkillzZz

Fatality didnt even reach the final to play against GitzZz on ESWC.

Blame it on the kung-fu style called Zulg :)

Ninja strikes again :f

fatal1ty !

GitzZz.. since I really dislikes Fat's american look. :)

fatality,

he went from q3 to ut2k3, won the cpl with ease. I'd love to see a UT player doing that in Quake3 :\/

yeah, but at cpl there was no serious competition, any european lan would have been much more difficult to win.

Oh yeah, beating zulg and infinite in a CPL tournament is no real competition indeed.

zzz

no gitzzz,lauke,frag^m ....
and zulg is better at tdm i think, well hes a top dueller too

zulg and infinite are both very good, and you called them no competition. Don't add new stuff.

True, but keep in mind that fat's favorite map (Insidious) was overly used in the CPL's 1-map=win structure. The map was probably the most hirrobly designed 1on1 map ever, and that's why guys like zulg hadn't practised it. Also the reason why no serious tourney except for the CPL used it.

fat on the other hand had practised it into oblivion, hence the 25-0 win there (if I recall correctly).

Don't get me wrong, I ain't saying that it wasn't a considerable achievement. But there are factors involved that made that particular CPL... 'different'.

True :P
Insidius is so funny that you can't really practice anything there ;P Just another morbias ;P Aside that you cannot show you skilz there too :P Whole CPL Winter UT2k3 was just too funny and can't be consider as competitve level tournament :P

Good that zulg^m ;P got his revenge later ar ESWC :P

(hey I did picture of that famous ZulgPad, anyone want to buy ?:P).

btw. of zulg... some nice quotes from carmac vs zulg ut2k3 match ;P

<WCGReport> [07:27] dfp.carmac(-1/12): i am like your private therapist responsible for relaxation

<WCGReport> [04:22] zulg[f](20/0): if you are gonna stand and do the q3-railgun dance
<WCGReport> [04:18] zulg[f](20/0): atleast do it with the shield up mmmkay

<WCGReport> [00:15] dfp.carmac(3/25): dunno what this is about but getting hammered by you is lots more fun than getting hammered by lauke
<WCGReport> [00:01] zulg[f](25/4): thats because you are a fanboy!

<WCGReport> [00:00] zulg[f](25/4): that "running at other guy with assaultrifle" tactic is almost working!

quality =)

Pure comedy =)

Actually, ask the players who were there :P.

gitzz for winning every international tournament he attended

he also defeated fata

its easy.
gitz won a tournament where fatality attended so.. ;P

gitzzz~~

fatality never really came back after his dominating year(s).
he said he would be great in ut, but wasnt that great, same with cs. he was great, but his talkin about how grea he is and could be a great player in everyfps game made me think that he is only a poser who is nowatimes outnumbered by better players(which shouldnt blame him, his time is only over).
though im playin quake, i think gitzzz should even win this tournament, because he is the absolute topplayer in ut and no player is more considered to be the perfect player.

he never came back? winning a cpl in a new game and beeing in a top cs team (that beat SK) and placing top3 in several touraments in several games is nothing? i think peaple rate 2nd and 3rd placed too low compared to a 1st.

"beeing in a top cs team (that beat SK)"

pardon? what team are you talking about and when did that mysterious team beat sk?

and btw, I've read somewhere that he had no luck to ever play with his CS team. They didn't allow Fat to play in their matches ;>

when exactly did Fat and his team inevitable Fate beat SK? the two teams never played against each other, Fat only played a few mixes with the SK.swe guys and got owned.

GitzZz 4 me. I dont like fat.

imo this poll isn't about who dominates the respective games they play, it's about their dedication, staying power and image and track record. IF you make the argument that you voted for Gitzzz because he dominates at UT then by those same merits we'd have voted for ZeRo4 or cooller if he were in it to win over their opponents simply because they are the best at quake3. But, that doesn't make any sense and obviously, ZeRo4 lost his challenge. This is why fatal1ty should win this match up. You can't expect fatal1ty to be extremely dominant in 1 game when he has switched etc so many times. And the fact is, he was extremely dominant back when he got his start as a pro-gamer in Quake3. His track record in Quake3 alone is astonishing, then, he moved on to AvP2 and won that tournament hands down, and also won the ut2k3 cpl championship shortly after he started playing the game altogether. He wasn't an extremely dominant player in ut2k3, but he had no prior UT background and less experience in the game altogether, so of course GittZzZ has him beat in UT because that's all he has to focus on. might i also note that fatal1ty RECENTLY switched to counter-strike and his team placed very well at the cXg tournament which never really officially went down correctly, yet they were very impressive in that tournament only weeks after forming the team. Fatal1ty has won World Cyber Games in Quake3, and the largest prize money ever given out to 1 person to my knowledge ($40,000) at razer CPL for Quake3. He was dominant over ANYONE in the world in quake3 at that time. He even came back after switching to ut2k3 with no practice at all and was 1 overtime frag short of qualifying for wcg 2002, in the same year he shutout ZeRo4 (2nd best in the world) in quake3 with no practice at Quakecon 2002.

if you think this shouldnt only sum up the dominance of someone, you might be right. it should also be who is a great person himself, and sorry, wihtin this aspect our extreme-arrogant fatality wouldnt win a flower.
fat was in the time when he won wcg the best q3er. but then came better people, and thats the fact. winning avp2 was not equal to his q3-achievements, same with the cpl ut2k3 thing, where no good player attended.
i dont say fatality is a bad player, its a real great thing how much he achieved and has won. but when you ask me who is the better player, its definitely gitzzz, cause he also has somethin fat always had a lack of... teamplay.

by the way i want to know who told you about this "no practice at all things", fat trained for all big tournaments defnitely the most. for the wcg qualifications where he lost to chaoticz in the overtime, he trained 8hours a day for 3months! at this point he showed, that he only was only talking very much with comebacks, but he wasnt able to come back to the absolute top.

Gitzzz - the best...

fatal1ty ! hes tah best YO!

Fatality owns!

i voted for fatal1ty, but it was a tough decision.

gitz
2 wcg's is bullshit, imo he would have won the third if germany would have had qualifiers

GitzZz! Fatal1ty is the Microsoft of gaming! Dont let his ego win!

And if the poll was "Most Influential Software Company", we wouldn't vote for Microsoft? It's this whole teenage angst and rebellion thing which is sort of a problem in this poll. GitzZz is highly-skilled, no doubt, but as you said, Fatal1ty is the MS of gaming - he's the institution to which everyone is compared - the industry leader.

We're talking about a highly-skilled single gamer to the most successful western multi-gamer through time. Is it _really_ that hard to decide?

GitzZz because he is the greatest gamer :X

faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaataaaaaaaaaaaaaaliiiiiiiiiiity!

Next time, can we get a 'Cutest Gamer Of All Time' poll? Fatal1ty wins that one, hands down.

lol?

He wouldn't...
...but his tiger would

hrhr omg I wanted write exacly the same about his tiger ;P

Hard one. Gitzzz get's it though

fatal1ty ownz .... only one choose in this question

GItzz krutoi papashka!!!
FatAL -> greabannyi ZADROT!!!

RUS with GITZZ!!

i think a big factor here is that gitzz is german. knowing what the germans are like regarding games like this its very hard for gitzz to promote himself as such, unlike usa where they push anyone into the spotlight if they are good.

so, that means that gitzz is well known purely for his skill as a gamer (regardless of game, this isnt a poll about who would beat who in x game) where as fat is well known for his skill yes, but also for his promotion.

Gitzz has dominated the ut series of games, he has not fallen to the wayside, or given up on a game as more ppl come to the top, he has just brushed them away.
Fat has dominated q3 then left when others were at his level (zero4 for a start) he owned avp2 (not hard considering it wasnt a viable platform for a competitve game so not many would of taken it seriously) and then he had some time at the top of ut2003, yet when UT's best joined the fold he failed to show.

Yes its great that fat has done so well in so many games, but then hes had the backing to goto so many tourneys. Gitzz would of won more if there was more to win.

Its a hard decision for those left to vote, but its worth actually thinking before you just vote for fat coz of all his winnings and his self promoting.

Never thought it that way. :X

Clever, clever.

thanks :>

Anytime, mr. teethless during honeymoon :D

rofl

:E to :F hehe

"so, that means that gitzz is well known purely for his skill as a gamer"

Simply beautiful sentence. n1

:D

GitzZz :)

geeeeez, this is such a no brainer. if gitzzz could play q3 as well as fatality can play ut2003, then it might be a slightly more difficult choice.

gitz UT > UT2k3 < Q3 fatal

Don't take wrong UT and UT2k3, they are way diffrent games. And Fatal started play/practice UT2k3 earlier than gitz.

So if Fat goes somewhere close to GitzZz in UT, he could be consider as better because of his multiplatform gaming, but he is not :P

chose gitzz, because fatality is sooo ugly xD

There both class gamers.. tho i never played fat and i did play gitzzz a few times, and im also an UT players, im voting for gitzzz.

GitzZz is definitly more skilled but Fatal1ty is the most well known.. :<

GitzZz !!!!1112

gitzzz, hes just like a legend for the ut community... nothing more to say

Lol, nobody has commented on the 'insane' bias shown in the player summaries here. Carmac, erm, I mean whoever wrote Gitz's bio sounds like he can't type without his tongue embedded in sweet anal ring, while Fatal1ty is made to sound like a freakish loser who does fuck all but practice games. Insane.

"GitzZz is not only an extraordinary player and a global gaming icon. He is also a very modest and friendly person who’s there for the competition, not for the money. "

Thanks for making those judgments for me , asshole. How about I decide for myself whether he's modest or friendly, and how the fuck do you know he's "there for the competition, not for the money?" What a load of shite..

fatality dominated in a game where LEGENDARY Quake players from Q1, Q2, and QW all competed for huge cash prizes. If you don't believe the competition was a little more stiff than some local german lans for 250 bux top prize, you are deluding yourself into a fantasy world, where you reside with a mere handful of other, equally delusional UT players. And as long as we're talking about winning WCG's, didn't destrukt win the first WCG for UT? I mean lets not keep rabbiting on about GitzZzZZ and how he has dominated UT like he's the only fucking name to ever grace the game.. he wasn't even AROUND when the first big tourney was going down. Destrukt himself LEFT UT for QUAKE3, because, in his exact own words "There just isn't enough competition in UT"

In summary, be objective in your reporting and stop trying to poison someones image with dogshit journalism, while simulataneously offering up your asshole like an overeager faggot. It makes you and this site look really really bad.

your dog died this morning or something?

It's a common fact here on ESR that Carmac likes to trash Fatal1ty.

Carmac didn't write the fatal1ty introduction.

How is that? Please give me an example.

Still waiting.

YES listen to mr. anonymus here, lmao..

u clearly made ur point that u DONT like UT, u dont have to call ppl assholes becouse they like some1 tho, bit lame dont u think?

neway, cant be arsed to write more, ur post is obviously based uppon ur interest in Q3 and ur defonatly a fanboy.

Fatal1ty did some great things, but as morba stated, AFTER q3 he didnt dominate anything at all, he was there, and won some american compo's, but thats it(correct me if im wrong).

He did not dominate. But he placed pretty well at ESWC and CXG (without practice).
And he won CPL Winter, 10000 dollars, which was pretty ace imo.

aye.. ofcourse its nice, i couldnt say i could do better. But its not ALL about the money. When im boting i also look at if they pressed there mark on the community(they both managed) and flexibility(also they both managed to play on high lvl in different games). No doubt there both v. skilled players, but for some reason i just feel gitzZz is better... maybe its also becouse i never talked to fatal1ty on irc and never played against him or something, so thats probably also swaying my judgement. Anyway, there both great gamers but thats the problem in these polls, they truly are all great gamers ;D

We KNOW you couldnt do any better.

yes, you are indeed a funny man, u got something usefull to say? else dont bother to reply

This site is full of ironic postings such as yours. Move along, nothing to see here.

ur the one posting ironic, and just becouse i dont got alot doesnt mean im not around long dude, so stop talking like u own the place.

dont bother replying, it will only prove im right.

You don't got a lot of money? You don't got a lot of crumbs on the floor? What? Dude wheres your car.

raterd

From the spelling of your post I'm assuming you are a R-E-T-A-R-D. Day release from the local spastic shelter is it?

yuo ar te onle raterd heere fro yuor infarmotion

Nice point, just keep it more calm next time :x
/me goes for gitzzz anyway, cause i am bit sentimental bout UT

"'insane' bias shown in the player summaries here"

Good, then the people who wrote the profiles have succeeded. They are suppose to be biased, they are suppose to be a celebration speech for that player. The case was to promote that particular player as the greatest gamer of all time.

and I just want to clarify, I really don't give a crap about this poll and who wins, my only real problem is with the blatant nut huggery of Gitzz, while Fat's profile seems more like an underhanded attempt to tear him down. I'm not really a fan of either, altho I will admit I believe Q3 to be 5x more competitive of a scene.

ok im unsure as to gitzz's whereabouts for the original wcg.
however once he reached the top he stayed there.

I thought only Americans attended that tournament because it was a sort of test for the real WCG which started in 2001. As I remember UT didn't have that much competitions in the form of Big Lan Tourneys early on.

your right about the tourneys, it never had blanket coverage like cs and q3.

thanks for info on the wcg :>

There were big lans in UT but from euro's point of view. In US Q3 had CPL and UT nothing. Thats probably why Destukt move from UT to other games.

yes.. thank for the disinformation. Tons of euros went to wcg 2000, maybe not for UT, but isn't that just another strike against the competitive scope of the UT scene? The first one being of course, that Gitzzz has won 2 wcg's. I don't care how good you are, but if you are winning 2 wcg's with relative ease, how can you not look at that as a lack of competition, as opposed to an overriding greatness? The third and final blow to this whole UT delusion is the fact that fatality reached THE UPPER ECHELON OF THE SCENE IN ONE 5 MONTH PRACTICE SESSION. YOU HAVE GOT TO BE KIDDING ME. I should bloody well hope you have an excuse for this one, because wow man, the more I think about it, the sadder it all seems.

It wasn't disinformation because I was refering to UT portion of the tournament which was a joke because not every UT player in the world had the chance to attend.

The third and final blow to this whole UT delusion is the fact that fatality reached THE UPPER ECHELON OF THE SCENE IN ONE 5 MONTH PRACTICE SESSION.

First of all fat made to the top of UT2k3 scene not UT which is a different game just like Quakeworld is different game from Q3. Secondly Fat also made it to the top of Quake 3 scene in 3 months so your point is moot. He is a great gamer so he can very good in any game he devotes himself to.

I don't care how good you are, but if you are winning 2 wcg's with relative ease, how can you not look at that as a lack of competition, as opposed to an overriding greatness?"

Tell me did the "great fatal1ty" qualify for the "easier" UT2k3 WCG????

Duh, it was a NEW game. Most UTers also only had 5 months of UT2003. Sure there were some things that transferred (dodging, combo) but for the most part they had to learn from scratch also.

fat started practising UT2k3 sooner than most UT players did... what's your point?

It is insane that I didn't write the Fatal1ty profile and yet you trash me for it :).

Yes, GitzZz is there for the competition. For the first time I met him in Milan, we were both at NGI LAN 2 / WCG.it. At that event one of the best UT players in the world, vicious (if you don't know, he was named as one of the favourites of the WCG tournament, next to lauke and GitzZz, who incidentally beat GitzZz and flocutus in the nations vs nations competition a year earlier with Ryo-Saeba), decided that he doesn't want to participate. All of vicious' friends tried to make him change his mind. We tried absolutely everything and he still said no. Then I went to GitzZz and asked him to ty and talk to vicious. Do you know what he did? He was trying to presuade vicious to change his mind for a half hour and when he realised it was futile, he sat for almost an hour in a corner, dejected. Keep in mind that without vicious the $20,000 at WCG would be A LOT easier.

As for destrukt, he won the WCGC with players from the US, UK, Canada and Korea. Some world championship, heh? And you seem to be forgetting destrukt failed to take the WCG title from GitzZz because he didn't even qualify from the US in 2002. destrukt left UT because there were not enough tournaments, this had nothing to do with the number of skilled players.

you may as well have written it, since I know who wrote it and I know he's your butt-buddy who shares your same, warped view of fatality. All this crap about UT vs Q3 is a moot point anyway, my post was intended to bring up the startling disparity in treatment of players, and how their images are projected in their profiles. The writing here is never that great to begin with, but you would think that if this was meant as an objective competition, you wouldn't try so hard to sway votes. Just let the people of this site decide who is the better gamer, however they understand it (and they did, albeit in a LOT closer fashion than I think Gitzz deserved).

My points about fatality and his ability to rise to greatness in a short time either will work against, or for me. But in the end, this point can do nothing but work FOR him, never against. Unless you are willing to go out on a limb and say one scene has more talent than the other, it can't be denied that fat was able to produce extremely good results in both games. Q3 he dominated early, and was able to stay near the top even when he was doing multiple games (Qcon 2k1 was after he had finished with AVP2) Ut2k3 he won at as well, but with less success overseas. If you'll remember, he was already making the switch to counterstrike when he failed to qualify for 2k3 WCG... Either way, he is now a solid performer in a relatively higher up CAL-I top 10 level CS clan, which is just another egg he can throw in his basket.

Fatality defines what it means to be a gamer, a really fucking hardcore gamer. If you've ever talked to him, sure, he doesn't come across as a humble, intellectual ambassador, who quietly lauds others while putting himself down. He might not be well-spoken, or even gracious in defeat, but really, how many people are? You just hear it more from him because he's very often in a position where his comments are heard. Fuck that anyway, so what if he's a brash, cocky, confident kid who honestly believes he has more gaming talent than most, if not everyone. Whether or not thats true, well, you can decide that, but I sure as hell wouldn't bet against him too much, because he has a tendency to win or come very damn close, and to me, thats what defines a great gamer.

The person who wrote the profile for Fatality is a Fatality fan. I am sorry if he disappointed you in the way he wrote it, I am hardly the one blameworthy here. About swaying votes - we were specifically asked to write the profiles in such a manner as to try and make the gamer look like he deserves the absolute #1 spot. And again, I am sorry that Fatality's profile did not meet your expectations in this respect.

I never said Fatality did not produce bad results, although I said he failed to ever live up to Fatality'2K. I believe QuakeCon was in the Summer and the car Fatality won at CPL Winter. Ask the players who were at CPL Winter for UT2003 to tell you how serious they think the tournament was (the only thing serious about it was the prize money). Anyway, I do not think that for someone who can afford to play a dozen hours a day to play a game for a living there can be mitigating factors for not qualifying to a WCG.

I did not bring up Fatality's cocky attitude in the thread at all, although I took it into account when placing my vote. I believe he has the right to act in a way that will sell him best or suit him best, I have no problem with that. I do know people who are humble after their losses - zulg or ZeRo4 might serve as very good examples here.

I'm also glad you managed to almost keep petty insults away from your comment.

fatality dominated in a game where LEGENDARY Quake players from Q1, Q2, and QW all competed for huge cash prizes. Blue, Lakerman, Makaveli, Treble, Trinidy, Venture, czm, wombat, Xenon, DOomer, Timber, Zero4, etc etc.. These names might not be familiar to you Carmac, but rest assured, to many quake fans these are god-like names, some of them so revered, I dare not mention that fat beat most of them, and his only losses came at the hands of the very best of them... Oh well, to each their own. Gitzzz like, could totally beat some guy named vicious, even tho vicious was totally vicious. Why exactly _did_ vicious not participate in that qualifier? thats what i want to know...

Do you mean to say that because you have not heard of legendary UT players there were none? GitzZz did face players of the same status of the UT comminity as the respective id-game legends. (vicious' reasons: http://www.esreality.com/?a=post&id=595313)

At the same time, Fatality lost games to people who, with all respect to them, are not absolute world class. That's in UT2003 as well as Quake 3.

Of course you have the full right to value Fatality's dominance in 2000 and his further years higher than I do (had he left in his prime I would have had no doubt who to vote for). I respect your opinion, please respect mine.

I believe we have somewhat strayed from the subject, that is the bias with which the profiles were written. As I have explained, they were supposed to be biased from the very beginning. It may be that GitzZz's profile is biased but everything that it is not is exagerrated.

Do you mean to say that because you have not heard of legendary UT players there were none?

No, I mean to say that Quake has a competitive field spanning 3 different games, BEFORE quake3 even existed. UT starts with.. UT. Don't even try to say their was Unreal legends, because I will laugh. Not that I'm not already.

GitzZz did face players of the same status of the UT comminity as the respective id-game legends. (vicious' reasons: http://www.esreality.com/?a=post&id=595313)

How is that possible, seeing as how those Quake legends came down from 3 different games?


At the same time, Fatality lost games to people who, with all respect to them, are not absolute world class.

Thats where you are just plain wrong, everyone loses games, at least in games where there is real competition, but believe me, everyone in the top 8 of any international tourney is 'world class' or they wouldn't be there.

That's in UT2003 as well as Quake 3.

Of course you have the full right to value Fatality's dominance in 2000 and his further years higher than I do (had he left in his prime I would have had no doubt who to vote for). I respect your opinion, please respect mine.

I can't respect your opinion, because its not based in reality, and you apparently have no appreciation for the level of skill and dedication it takes to be #1 in the world


I believe we have somewhat strayed from the subject, that is the bias with which the profiles were written. As I have explained, they were supposed to be biased from the very beginning. It may be that GitzZz's profile is biased but everything that it is not is exagerrated.

No, we have strayed onto a new subject, one that I believe you are totally and utterly uninformed about, and Gitzzz's profile makes character judgments that are really best left to oneself. It would be like heaping praise on Kobe Bryant for his impeccable image. You don't know whats really going on inside a person, so don't write like you do.

^ Fat came to dominate the legends from 3 different games yet he can't really dominate legends from one game (UT). It just seems that the real life results contradicts your opinion that Quake 3's level of competition is much higher. No matter what you think is logical i.e. since Quake 3 had more competition since it has more "legends" from previous games it doesn't really matter if it is not proven by empirical evidences.

There were UT legends, yes. Those three games of experience don't mean much if your Q3 god comes and gets beaten by players who are not top 8 in the world, does it?

Oh, I do have an appreciation for the level of skil and dedication it takes to be #1 in the world. Especially for three years, as opposed to one... (that's, of course, if you disregard AvP2 ;P)

I am misinformed? Now that's interesting. Tell me where I'm wrong, then.

Gitz won WCG 2001 + 2002

Fatal WIN!

GitzZz is real progamer.
Fat-is real businesmen.
GitzZz is Best of the best.(after Polos Afcoss)

ROFL at the Anonymous poster. GitzZz didnt win a "few German LANs". hes won every major tournament hes ever been in. fatality has NOT. fatality has left games after people started catching up to his 8 HOUR PRACTICE TIMES. GitzZz owned the game until the sequel game out. what did he do then? owned the sequel. and WHO did he own in the sequel? among others, FATALITY.

some people try to bring bullshit arguments in like "UT has less skill, thats why fatality didnt win every tournament!". bullshit argument, me saying q3 is for noobs has just as much validity. none.

and as for is he modest and humble? how the hell are you going to "decide for yourself" if you never plan on meeting the guy? even if you did, you sound like the guy that would just start talking shit when he owned you. ive talked to him, and he doesnt talk shit, and wont even promote himself IN A PM ON IRC. i tried to coax him into saying he was the best dueller, and all that he would do is give credit to his teammates. thats HUMBLE, especially after owning just about everyone pretty damn consistently.

ive known people who hate fatality BECAUSE of his attitude. god forbid you beat him and he doesnt think your worthy.

and finally, this is a BEST GAMER poll. not best shameless self promoter. if gaming ever became a "sport", gitz would be the ideal personage of a REAL professional gamer.

P.S. im american.

I think the most impressive thing about GitzZz is the way he plays. He is always in perfect control, he rarely walks into trouble. If he get's an early lead in a game it is pretty much over since he is so solid. Flawless timing combined with godly aim and a very strategic mind.

I think GitzZz is a more impressive gamer when looking at demos, GitzZz is as optimal a gamer as you can ever see (even more than Cooller on ZTN and Zero4 on PT4). But I still went with fat because of more wins in very different games. But it's as close to a 50/50 call you can get, if you ask me.

For me most impressive is his cool head. He isn't nervous when playing and thanks to this he always manage to win.

I understood that when watching more closly polish best ut dueller, because he has the same attribute.

I just think much more highly of GitzZz as he's stuck with his game, doesnt go around promoting himself and is simply a much cooler player. From the demos I've seen, Fatal1ty is a lot less great to watch.

Too sad GitzZz will probably loose this one - he really is the best :(((

WTF 're u talking about??? GitzZz never lose before and he will never lose after! =)

GITZZZ OWNED FATAL1TY EVERYTIME THEY MET!

Vote Gitz :P

Saw him at AMD ProGamers Challenge 2002 in Prague (which he won) and understand that there can be human aimbot :P On the other hand I saw fat only by GTV @ QuakeCon 2k2 (and he wasn't worth watching).

Also 2x WCG, ESCW etc.
Fat has nice scores over the world but they aren't so spectacular as Gitz.
And he did poorly in UT2k3 while Gitz showed in idealistic way why new biorifle is bad (by owning everybody with it in eliminations;P).

I just can't find in Fatal1ty play nothing exciting :P

do u remember that fat's hiding vs zulg on compressed (ESWC)?

:)) exciting :D

haha, yeah man. one of the most miserable games i've ever seen. and still fat wins the poll - what a pity.

He did same @ QuakeCon 2k2 on ospdm8... and then he lost in looser bracket :P

3rd ESWC is poorly?
People come on, not only 1st places are worldclass, 2nd/3rd/4th etc should not be forgotten as well!
my god

stfu short arse, just becuasey our not the best promode player and i am :/

no h8 :\

stfu :(
Or else I will make a mirror from your head :/

owned :(

yeah :(

at least im not convinced you cheat anymore :D

hehehehe :P
I always disable them on lan.

pr0.

Well... if gitz goes 2nd or 3rd I would start consider this places as worldclass :P But he don't ;PPP hrhrhrhrhr ;P

Don't get me wrong. He did nice, other top places are important... but "he" was far away from first 2 :P

i vote for gitzz because hes one helluva player. His patience with his game and attitude and thats what makes a tru pro game player.As for fatal1ty i dont know really well so i coundt vote for him.

what About M19|Lexer everyone forgot about the best quake 3 player in the world :X

HEY LOOK!

52% of the voters have no clue what this poll is about!

Fat is a great gamer no doubt.He ownt everyone in the early days of q3.Hes cocky and hes been interviewed, like, 23495927 times-thats what i dont like about him.q3 is also older/more popular and faster game so I think its harder to be undefeated champion of it,since so many ppl played for so long.Gitzzz beat Fat at UT2003,but whould he beat him in q3?I really doubt it.I voted Fat cuz I loved hes early q3 demos,such beautiful strong and sharp action.My favorite was him against Makavelli on dm13.

Well....
Fatality got full controll in quake3 when he plays...
Download fatality vs zero4 dm6 qcon2k2...
Its so impressive..... And fatalityvs Aim ???
who said fatality has no control ???
he controls the game so much.......

GitzZz has won most of UT competions
of course Fatality is top player but not as good as GitzZz.
when MTV were making Fatality movie GitzZz wasnt playing in that competition so ppl thought that Fat is greatest, but look at the scores, GitzZz has really beat Fatality many many times and got many 1-st places.

well i guess gitz didnt win every competition he competed in ... he just lost here :)

fatality all the way.

if GitZzZ wins a high level competition of QUAKE 3, then I'll think about voting for him.

of course this poll is finished but you got the idea..

Going same way - if fatal1ty wins a high level comtetition of UT, then I'll think about voting for him :PPP

does cpl mean anything?
:PPP

In Poland and UT not much :P

Going same way again: does WCG mean anything ? :P


Fat never played in UT, and never won anything in this game.

He played only in completly different UT 2003 and Gitz did better in it.

So:
Fat: he dominate Q3 for some time, played good in ut2k3
Gitz: dominate UT to the end, played top in ut2k3

WCG and ESWC is way more important for me, also fat gamestyle is little boring for me, and gitz is impressing me :P

"Fat never played in UT, and never won anything in this game."

eh? first of all, i didn't said fat was good at UT, i don't know why the fuck you brought it up.

"Going same way again: does WCG mean anything ? :P"

yea, fat won wcg once :)

"played good in ut2k3"

winning one cpl and third @ eswc is 'good'? switching from another game? yea ok.

^ He was just using the same argument that you used against gitzzz i.e "if GitZzZ wins a high level competition of QUAKE 3, then I'll think about voting for him." On the opposite of the coin since Fat never won a high level competition of UT I am not going to vote for him either. This just shows how ridiculous your original argument is to compare these two players in a game (quake 3) in which one player (gitzzz) never played.

Fat is a world class player at UT2k3 but he didn't exactly dominate the same way he did in Quake 3 in 2000.

fat played ut2k3 and won the cpl, my point is that no other player have the dedication to switch from one game to another and win a tournament like the cpl for example. get it now?

Do you have some problem understanding me. My response is related to fws's comment: "Fat never played in UT, and never won anything in this game." and your rebuttal "eh? first of all, i didn't said fat was good at UT, i don't know why the fuck you brought it up."

You are puzzled why did he brought it up so I gave you answer.


BTW UT2k3 is a different game from UT so you can argue that all the UT players that bothered to switch to it also have the dedication that Fat has. (Well maybe not because none of them practiced 12 hours a day)

Exacly :P

Thanks for explaining him what the point was but as we can see some people have problem with understanding basic ideas :P